Had been meaning to post this for a while, but was hesitant of putting in the effort, particularly, since it's largely meaningless. Anyway, decided to bite the bullet on a lazy Sunday afternoon. So, here goes
Here are the Wikipedia links for 10 drafts from 2011 to 2020. The reason I excluded the last 4 is that the story is yet to be written for those. Wanted a largish sample, since it evens out good/bad drafts, some reaches being successful, while some projected stars falling short etc. Focusing on the top 10 players in each draft. Again, this means that the team is solidly in the lottery, but not necessarily bad enough for a top-5 pick. If we do decide to "tank", we might be in a similar situation. So, here goes
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_NBA_draft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_NBA_draft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_NBA_draft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_NBA_draft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_NBA_draft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_NBA_draft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_NBA_draft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_NBA_draft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_NBA_draft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_NBA_draft
- Number of All-Stars (not total selections; just the number of players out of 100 who made at least 1 all-star team):
- 2011: 2
- 2012: 4
- 2013: 1 (Victor Oladipo)
- 2014: 3
- 2015: 3
- 2016: 3
- 2017: 3
- 2018: 3
- 2019: 3
- 2020: 2
- Total: 27
- All-NBA (Again, at least 1)
- 2011: 2
- 2012: 4
- 2013: 1 (Victor Oladipo)
- 2014: 2
- 2015: 2
- 2016: 2
- 2017: 2
- 2018: 2
- 2019: 1
- 2020: 1
- Total: 19
- Franchise Players (my subjective opinion)
- 2011: 1 (Kyrie)
- 2012: 2 (Anthony Davis, Lilard)
- 2013: -
- 2014: 1 (Embiid)
- 2015: -
- 2016: 1 (Jaylen Brown)
- 2017: 1 (Tatum)
- 2018: 1 (Doncic)
- 2019: -
- 2020: 1 (Anthony Edwards)
- Total: 8
So, out of 100 players, 27 made an All-Star team, 19 made an All-NBA team, and 8 are what I would label as franchise players. While the first two sections are based purely on data (e.g., Oladipo making an All-NBA team in 2013. I don't remember the season he had, but I wouldn't want to tank for him), the last part is my opinion. So, I have not included Zion and Ja. Others might include them. Based on talent, they both qualify. However, they both have serious issues, due to which I excluded them. Others might include them, or some players I left out (including e.g., Simmons, Randle)
All in all, these are not stellar numbers. 27% chances of landing an All-Star, and 19% of landing an All-NBA don't seem all that bad, but they include relatively weak selections. Moreover, if you are hoping for a HOF type of franchise player, chances go down to 8%.
Sure, these odds improve if you restrict yourself to a top 5 pick (14%), but I hope folks can see that even a top 5 pick gives you only a 14% chance of landing a superstar.
The more interesting point is that many of these players are not playing for the franchise that drafted them. From the above list of franchise players, only Embiid, Brown, Tatum, and Ant are playing for the teams that drafted them.
This is not necessarily bad. Many had success with the clubs that drafted them, and when they left, they often brought back value. However, small market teams in particular, need to put a good product on the floor quickly. Else, they might lose their star. In the current environment, with star players holding franchises hostage, you might not get a lot either.
To all the folks on the Tank bandwagon, I can understand the desire, since the team seems to be stuck in a loop of mediocrity. With us potentially losing our FRP, hoping for some lottery magic in a supposedly good draft definitely has an appeal. Do remember that if we do get lucky in lottery, chances of landing a franchise player with a top-5 pick hover at around 14%. There is also a good chance that we will Kangz it, or see the young stud we drafted blossom elsewhere.
I still believe that Vivek should retain Monte, and give him some time to balance out the roster. That said, if we tank, we should ship out anyone not named Keegan, Keon, Laravia, Jones, and Carter, and get what value we can for them. While I would love to have Domas, there is no point having him on a rebuilding roster. He wouldn't want it either. In fact, it's possible Keegan might ask out too.
Good luck trading all those salaries suddenly. The NBA salary cap is going to rise significantly over the next few years. So, currently large salaries will be easier to trade from next year. Even so, you can't trade large salaries without taking back a good percentage of them, and then have them ride the bench, trade them again for more assets, etc. Too many variables. I would rather the team balances out the roster a bit, and develops via internal growth from the young guys.