I agree about using hindsight, but I said look at his whole career. You and I both know Collins was not the reason that team went 13-3. Their defense was superb, they were physical and had Chris Johnson. Collins looked ****ing awful, just terrible. And it's not Fisher that made the change, it was the owner. Not like he made this astute move.
I think Jeff Fisher is overrated. The way the team came to life this season probably saved his job, because after that 59-0 beating against the Pats, his seat was the hottest it's been since he's been there.
About Carroll. The university needs him NOW more than ever. He's a good coach, probably as good as that University will get, he had the name, the success under his name. If the school is going to get sanctioned, that means it will be more difficult, not easier, to get players and to build a successful program - now is when he should have put forth the effort. I think he believed that he needs to cash in while he's still hot, he worried about his legacy and bolted. The way he did it too was pretty ****ty. Not telling his players and just bolting. I hate dishonesty, hate weasels. I'm probably still bitter that Mora was only given one year, but that's apples and oranges. I'll be the first to apologize and admit I was wrong, but man this just stank.
I don't buy the whole "he should stay for his recruits" thing. They don't stay for him. Their commitment is to the school, not the coach. It sucks, because the reason the university sends the head coach on recruiting trips is because the players want to play for a big name coach like Pete Carroll, but they have no guarantee that the coach is going to stay there. Hell, the coach could get fired, or have to take a leave of absence like Urban Meyer. You don't sign with the coach; you sign with the university.
And when you think about it, this story just broke on Friday. I know the recruits would have been anxious to know what the situation was, but it's only been a couple of days. We don't even know if he had gotten all his terms right with the Seahawks, or if he had tendered his resignation yet. Before you start calling recruits, you have to get all your stuff together. They'll be alright after waiting 48-72 hours.
That's the black and white of it. Now, I understand what you're saying, and I understand why players and their families would get upset in this situation. I'd be upset, too. But Pete Carroll has to do what makes the most sense for him. I don't think that makes him a bad person. He's been there for nine years, so it's not like he just used USC as a stepping stone to a better job. He's not jumping around every two years. He built the program into a winner, and this is not him deciding to leave after a bad year. All indications are that next year would be better than this year was. They lost four conference games for the first time in who knows how long. That wasn't going to happen again. They haven't lost a game out of conference since the Rose Bowl against Texas. Pete Carroll did a lot for USC, and if they play their cards right (and if the NCAA doesn't tie their hands too severely) they can remain a contender in the Pac-10.
The reason -- I think -- Pete Carroll is leaving, and the reason I would be leaving if I were him, is that it's too hard to maintain a powerhouse college football program. It's hard enough to build it, but then you have to rebuild it every two years? He lost half his defense and his quarterback last season. He's losing more star players this year. He loses coordinators and position coaches to other college programs (Sarkissian) and even NFL teams (Kiffen, Chow). His program gets looted every year. Now free agency in the NFL is going to cost you players, and the best coaches lose assistants all the time, but you have an opportunity to build a core and keep it largely in tact for a considerable period of time. In college, you have a complete turnover once every four years.
Another thing to consider is that the NFL is quickly becoming a young man's league. The hottest coaches in the NFL are under 50. Even the most prolific coaches are hitting their primes in their early 50s, and then falling off after that. You have to put in 16 hours a day, you have to travel all across the country, you don't spend as much time with your family. I know college coaches work hard, too, but the NFL is a different level, and has become a year round league from a fan's standpoint. Pete Carroll is 58. He's always said that he has unfinished business in the pros, but that he wanted to do it his way. This is probably his last chance to go to the NFL and have complete control. Over the years, he's turned down several high profile gigs because it wasn't the right fit, so it's not like he was just itching to get back in no matter what and was going to abandon USC as soon as he got the chance. Things just happened to come together perfectly, and he would have been a fool to walk away from it. It's his career. I think it's unfair and hypocritical to criticize someone for deciding to advance his career.