I usually end up just getting pepperoni, but that's more of a function of me being too cheap to pay for extra toppings. I don't generally think of pepperoni as my favorite, but it is the only topping I'll eat on a pizza, by itself, so maybe it is?I was half kidding about the pineapple.. it has its place but its not my favorite topping. I do find it hilarious though how some people just cannot stand the idea of it. One of my coworkers gets pissed if anyone orders pizza at work with pineapple on it and it cracks me up every time.
I like chicken, garlic, and white sauce on my pizza though if I get to pick so I know I'm a heathen.
If I feel like "splurging" on extra toppings, I can't go wrong with supreme, but Pepperoni/Mushroom/Pineapple is like comfort food, to me.