ummm im not a dwight defender by any means and believe he is somewhat overrated but you are completely wrong when comparing Yao to Dwight.
Yao only played 2 complete seasons as opposed to Dwights 5, plus a 78 and 79 game season. cant do much if your not on the floor.
better at defense? umm dwight won DPOY 3 years in a row and is 4x first team all defense.
Yao? zero defensive awards.
better at offense? Yao 52% from the field for his career, Dwight 58%. 19 pts 9 rebs for Yao and 18pts 13 rebs for dwight.
but those are just stats as you say Yao was a much more "complete" player?
matchups between the two? who cares they played eachother twice a year in meaningless regular season games, but if you would like to hang your hat on that to make a case for Yao being better, good luck.
and as i said before dwight took a team of nobodies to the finals, how far did yao take his teams? oh the second round once.
Read before you get all hot and bothered. I never said Yao is better at defense. I said Yao was a big reason why the Rockets team of that era was a good defensive team. Though he may be a better defender than Yao, it doesn't mean Yao is a bad defender.
What I'm getting at is Howard has only 1 real post move and it showed clearly this year when he loss some of his athleticism. If a guy that only has 1 move and dunks is the BEST, then this is seriously a sad sad time. A lot of people didn't watch Yao enough to appreciate how skilled he was. He can post from either side and hook with either hand, baseline fadeaways, etc. That is a complete center. That is why Shaq likes Bynum more than Howard (that 1 year) and I agree with him on that.
Howard was never a good on ball defender. He won those awards because he led the league in blocks and good team defense made him look better than he is. If you believe so firmly in those awards, explain why Roy Hibbert wasn't even in the 1st or 2nd all-defensive team when he anchored his team's #2 rated defense.
If you are comparing shooting percentages, try looking up Yao's free throws % vs Howard's. The Lakers loss more than a handful of close games the lakers loss this year when their opponents started hacking Howard. You can't be considered as "best" if you can't be depended upon down the stretch in games.
Regarding Howard taking his team to the finals, did you forget how weak the east was in those years vs the west? That team of nobodies you speak of had 3 all stars, high caliber role players such as Hedu (he was great those years), a team full of 3 point shooters and a good team defensive system.
That argument is completely flawed when you compare 2 players base on their teams when they played in difference conferences and had different role players. You can be as high as a 4th seed at one point with around a .500 record in the east. The Magic also got a big break that year from KG's knee if I remember correctly.
On the same note, I would easily pick our DeMarcus Cousins over Howard any day and I've been telling my friends that since his rookie year. A center is suppose to play in the post with his back to the basket and I can never call Howard the best when there are at least 5 centers currently thats better in the post than him.