Music Draft Playoffs Rnd 1: #7 kingsnation vs. #10 RookieOfTheDay

Which is the better list of music?

  • kingsnation

    Votes: 11 45.8%
  • RookieOfTheDay

    Votes: 13 54.2%

  • Total voters
    24
  • Poll closed .

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
#1


kingsnation
1.06 - U2
2.11 - Fleetwood Mac
3.06 - The Who
4.11 - Stevie Wonder
5.06 - Dave Matthews Band
6.11 - Snow Patrol
7.06 - Dr. Dre
8.11 - Mariah Carey
9.06 - Alicia Keys
10.11 - Linkin Park
11.06 - The Roots
12.11 - Louis Armstrong
13.06 - David Gray
14.11 - The Four Tops
15.06 - Hans Zimmer
16.11 - Jimmy Cliff
17.06 - P.O.D.
18.11 - Shakira
19.06 - Brooks & Dunn
20.11 - Goo Goo Dolls
21.06 - Ray LaMontagne
22.11 - Adele
23.06 - Wailing Souls
24.11 - Robert Randolph & the Family Band
25.06 - Earth Wind & Fire
26.11 - Matchbox Twenty
27.06 - The Mavericks
28.11 - Mary J. Blige
29.06 - Anberlin
30.11 - Underoath
vs.

RookieOfTheDay
1.16 - Pink Floyd
2.01 - The Doors
3.16 - Iron Maiden
4.01 - Yes
5.16 - Prince
6.01 - Depeche Mode
7.16 - Alice in Chains
8.01 - The Police
9.16 - Willie Nelson
10.01 - Madonna
11.16 - The Allman Brothers Band
12.01 - Soundgarden
13.16 - Scorpions
14.01 - Neil Young
15.16 - Megadeath
16.01 - Loreena McKennitt
17.16 - Primus
18.01 - UFO
19.16 - Jefferson Airplane
20.01 - Marty Robbins
21.16 - Yngwie Malmsteen
22.01 - Everly Brothers
23.16 - Jethro Tull
24.01 - John Williams (the classical guitarist)
25.16 - Jane's Addiction
26.01 - Ratt
27.16 - Symphony X
28.01 - Doc Watson
29.16 - King Diamond
30.01 - Grant Green
 
Last edited:
#2
Neither list is a slam dunk for me, but Prince has been one of my favorite artists for pretty much as long as I've been alive. That's enough for me to go with Rookie.
 
#4
U2 is my favorite among the 2 list, however, Rookie's list has more artists that I like. Doors, Maiden, AIC and Soundgarden among them.
 
#7
I think I actually ranked kingsnation higher but it was close. Either way, going with Rookie's list now as I think he and I have the most similar taste in music, even though I despise Pink Floyd.
 
#9
going with rookieoftheday here though kingsnation had some excellent selections (The Roots- whose new album 'undun' is simply spectacular, and The Mavericks- really like some of their stuff) but some of the big hitters on ROTD's list was just too much to overcome.
 

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
#10
Close one. Alright, we've got a bit of a holdup with the dukeswh/Dime Dropper tie, but I that will be resolved tommorow either through a top 5 vs. top 5 poll is dukes returns, or some other means if he does not. Either way, congrats Rookie, you'll be moving on to the second round. While kingsnation, despite his stated lack of interest, will probably be one of the favorites in the consolation bracket. :)