FaStRmAn
Starter
I try to look at the economic settings, players we have, future picks, things like that before judging the FO when it comes to improvement from say last year.
I also try to be honest about the coaching performance as well.
When you say "Karl isn't the problem" it hints at absolutes, its possible he makes a situation worse, or cannot make improvements on what we have. It's quite possible we need several things and he is rather useless in improving the situation himself.
This is what we have.
A "debatable" franchise player in Cousins, which I consider a legit franchise player but put it on the debatable level with all his critics here.
A solid role player draft pick in WCS.
A good valued contract for a "second tier guy" in Rudy
One of the best back up pg's on a cheap contract in Collison
Experienced role players in KK and Marco. KK contract is very movable, a Marco's may not be the best around but its not a lost cause either.
An expiring pg.
A underwhelming guy we've been trying to develop for a couple of years in Ben, who is at least cheap, with potential upside.
Economically we are sound, we can move just about anyone we wish without much trouble besides maybe Marco, I assume even he is, but find contract criticism there fair.
Karl has not improved anything.
A rookie GM who has not "ruined" us, and seems to of at least treated people decently and kept this place from blowing up.
All Vivek needs to do is get the GM call right this off season, who then follows up with the right coach. And he's got Vlade to help him make those calls. Vlade is a good networker, knows people, is probably talking with just about every organization he can on road trips with the team.
So the new GM should have a handle on what he has, how it mixes, some insight from Vlade to get things done right.
There is no new immanent doom now that we didn't have before, our options are more flexible now than they were before.
You could argue we wasted a year, but I'm not sure that's the case if we get the right people in the off season.
I agree that Karl is not improving anything. However we can not lay the blame 100% at his feet. If Malone had not done what he did and showed the fans that this team COULD compete, then I'd say that the coach is completely irrelevant. But the fact is that Vlade has the reigns now, and he does have options. They need to bring in new players to replace the players who are not succeeding for whatever reason. They desperately need a 2 guard who can defend his own shadow. McLemore isn't the answer (at least here anyway). Start with what you can fix. Go get a decent 2 guard and see how the season progresses. If it stays the same or gets worse, THEN make changes in the off season like stable franchises do.