I think that he did better than he gets credit for, but he still made some really crazy head scratchers. Like Papagianis really didn't cost us anybody but it was still a bad pick. We could have done better with the #10 pick than what we got, though Barnes was part of that so the fact that JJ is out of the league (or did someone pick him up?) doesn't matter as much. BUT - He certainly would have put this team into luxury cap territory re-signing Giles and Bogi whereas now we have the main core and a ton of trade or cap flexibility.
I am fine if we ditch Luke (hell I want to smack him in the face for how he wears his mask) but I don't think last season was a very fair way to evaluate given the amount of injury struggles and the fact that our big FA signing decided to basically quit after he got paid. The commentators did point out that he had more wins in his first season with the team than anyone since Theus, which was astounding. And obviously a huge disappointment after letting Joerger go, but it is some perspective I guess, when you factor in all the bad bounced that happened. I do think he has a much better team of assistants this year so we'll see. Already the team looks like they understand how to rebound.