Or because of injuries, or trades, or specific match up situations.
You know what I mean.
Or because of injuries, or trades, or specific match up situations.
I do. I just think it's a little early for statements about what is a failure and what isn't. Iman hasn't played ball in a while, is still somewhere near his physical prime, and is on a young team that at least wants to play fast. Given that scenario and his contract situation he may not be completely useless. If motivated he has the chops to be the best perimeter defender on the Kings.You know what I mean.
I remember watching this game where he was giving D. Rose, who was playing at an MVP level at the time, fits and thinking "He looks pretty good"..Here's a guy I don't want to see a single second of.
I won't trash him too hard, but he serves ZERO purpose on this team, and every single time I've ever watched him I've come away thinking "Dude is just terrible."
SLAB I always thought highly of you as a recognizable user around here, maybe it’s the Sam Cassell avi...but saying Iman serves no purpose on this team is shoddy analysis in my honest opinion. Whether it’s solid defense, a little athleticism, or the ability to knock down shots at a decent clip, if Shump can do any of these he will see considerable floor time as a veteran presence in Joegers system, sorry to be the one to break it to you.Here's a guy I don't want to see a single second of.
I won't trash him too hard, but he serves ZERO purpose on this team, and every single time I've ever watched him I've come away thinking "Dude is just terrible."
I do. I just think it's a little early for statements about what is a failure and what isn't. Iman hasn't played ball in a while, is still somewhere near his physical prime, and is on a young team that at least wants to play fast. Given that scenario and his contract situation he may not be completely useless. If motivated he has the chops to be the best perimeter defender on the Kings.
Whats the difference between Shumpert and Garrett Temple though
is he really expected to get any significant minutes though? It won't be long before he has his yearly injury and sits out, he can be a good cheerleader on the sidelines and come in and play some defense on occasions but other than that...meh
I get that. I don't know that it's quite that black and white. If Justin's progress is slow but positive then I can see Coach Joerger giving Iman some minutes at the 3 especially if he's defending well and hitting the 3 and bring Justin along off the bench or slowly revving up his minutes as he shows more. If something like that happens I don't believe it should be considered a failure. Of course Vlade could use our stable of bigs to trade for another SF and then all bets are off.It wasn't really a knock against Shump. It's more like if JJ fails and forces Joerger to play Shump big minutes or if Joerger plays him big minutes anyway and just sits JJ to try to eek out 30 wins instead of 29, then we're probably in trouble.
I'll go ahead and says he's nothing. Shump is nothing. The guy can't stay healthy to save his life. He can't even manage to get on the court an average of 55 games a season during his career. He's 28 and already past his mediocre prime. The year they won the championship he started a whole 5 games during the regular season. He also had the worst defensive plus/minus of his career and was 11th on the team in scoring just beating out a 78 year old Richard Jefferson who was playing significantly less minutes than him. With the Cavs showing very little confidence in him they started him 0 times during the playoffs. Yeah he got a ring but you could have put pretty much anyone in his place and they would have a ring. Look at his post season stats below that got him that ring, they are garbage.
View attachment 8230
Just to clarify, a players prime is considered to be between the ages of 27 and 32, so he's hardly past his prime. In fact, he just entered into his prime. You don't like him, fine! But don't make up crap to fit your agenda. To be honest, I haven't been his biggest fan, but he can defend, and if he can shoot consistently, which he has in the past, then he could help this team with his experience. If he gets injured, and can't play, we aren't losing someone that we expected big things out of.
The upside of him playing well, and getting the minutes to do so, is that he then becomes a trade asset at the trade deadline. Just because you don't like him, doesn't mean other teams won't. Strange how Lebron liked your nothing player. Shumpert plays with attitude, and that's something that this team needs. This is a contract year for Shumpert, so whatever we get from him, I can guarantee you it will be his best.
If I may say something about a defensive rating. Temple has always been considered a good defender. His defensive rating before coming to the Kings was always around 100. Sometimes a little over and sometimes a little under. However with the Kings, his defensive rating was hovering around 112 to 114. Did Temple suddenly become a bad defensive player? By the same token, Koufos defensive rating was around 103 on average until he got to the Kings. This last season it was 110, and that folks was the best defensive rating on the team. As matter of fact, Koufos and Willie have been taking turns being the best defensive player on the team the last few years.
Once again, did Koufos suddenly become a bad defender? No is the answer to both Temple and Koufos, but when your on a team surrounded by young inexperienced players, it's going to affect your overall rating. I don't think it's an accident that Willie's best defensive rating occurred when he was on the floor with Koufos. Your as good a defender as the players around you. For that reason you can't take the plus/minus or the defensive ratings at face value. You have to dig a little deeper to get the truth.
The reason I bring this up, is because people tend to use those ratings as the be all, end all, and they're not. As a matter of fact, they're far from it. I think over a long period of time, they can be useful, but as a short term measuring stick, I put little value in them. I'm more inclined to go with the eye test. If you disagree, then someone explain to me how Cousins can put up 25 points, grab 12 rebounds, have 5 assists, block a shot or two, and end up with a minus 15 rating. Somehow my brain has a hard time figuring out how Cuz had a negative impact on the game. It's all about the company you keep.
Offensive and defensive ratings are ridiculously swayed by what team you're on but hardly anyone here ever talks about them.
What is this minus 15 rating you're talking about with Cousins?
I just better not see Ben get minutes over shump.
I was referring to a particular game that Cousins played in while he was still with the Kings. It was one of many, and not just Cousins, but other Kings players who had good games, but got a minus rating. And, I agree with you that those ratings are swayed by who your on the floor with. I wasn't implying that those ratings were running rampart, but they are referred to from time to time and they don't carry much weight with me.
Hey, I go check the defensive ratings of players all the time, but I usually do a historical look as well, like I did with Temple and Koufos. It can help put things into a little different perspective. For instance, if by looking at Temple and Koufos, and realizing that their defensive rating is being inflated by who their playing with, then maybe I can apply that same logic to other King players.
The upside of him playing well, and getting the minutes to do so, is that he then becomes a trade asset at the trade deadline.
Dave loves guys who play like him e.g. Tony Allen/Temple while I would not want to see it, it would not surprise me at all.I'm gonna bet Shump starts at the 3
Uh yah he is far better than JJ. JJ is terribleHe's not better than JJ in the short term, and especially not in the long term.
Sounds like a vote of confidence for Ben McLemore to meThe worst guy in the NBA is still better than 99.99% of all the guys who have played basketball at any point in their lives. The mere fact they're part of the 450 young men who get to live the dream puts them far above the pale.
Shump is going to out perform all expectations this year. He is a forgotten man but mark my words he will be a very solid addition