I disagree that we need a third star. We need a second star. A star is a guy who can carry the team. We have nobody that can carry this team to victory when Cousins is out. Gay is a third wheel. A good third wheel. But still the third wheel. If, say, Durant is out, then Westbrook can carry the Thunder, or vice-versa. Those guys are stars.
I still think Westbrook can be a number 1 option on a very good team. The Thunder are fortunate that they have two players like Durant and Westbrook locked up, but just because Gay isn't as good as Westbrook doesn't mean he isn't a legit second wheel or that we keep looking until we find a second wheel as good as Westbrook.
Are there second options on other teams that are better than Gay? Yes. Are there second options on other teams that are worse than Gay? Yes.
When looking at the second options of teams that are either at or above .500 (threw in the Thunder as well), Gay has the third highest PPG of anyone (list below).
- Westbrook - 23.3
- Irving - 21.5
- Gay - 21.1
- K. Thompson - 20.9
- Wade - 20.5
- P. Gasol - 20.0
- Lillard - 19.7
- Nowitzki - 19.6
- DeRozan - 19.4
- Howard - 18.8
Not to mention he is doing it at an efficient clip 46%/34%/87%.
Now I know scoring is not everything when we're talking about second options, but Gay is not only a scorer. He's been effective at finding people and creating looks for his teammates. Out of all the second options that belong to the .500 or better teams, Gay ranks third in assists if you remove PGs (Wade & Evans are the only two that are averaging more this season). We've all seen Gay being doubled from time to time (hell he was doubled a handful of times last night). His scoring ability does require attention. Not as much as Cousins, but the defense is still drawn towards him.
Just really stop and think about the second options out there and ask yourself who would you rather have than Gay (full list of second options for .500 or better teams below)?
- DeRozan
- Gortat
- Millsap
- P. Gasol
- Irving
- Wade
- J. Parker
- Randolph
- K. Thompson
- Lillard
- Howard
- Leonard
- Nowtizki
- Paul
- Bledsoe
- Afflalo
- Evans
- Westbrook
Personally, if I had Cousins as the only player on my team, these are the players I would take over Gay: Paul (and that's if they didn't hate each other) & Westbrook with Lillard as a borderline maybe. That's it for me.
So when I see people saying Gay is not a second wheel, it makes me wonder who they think is better and who they think is better that we can possibly get. And with Cousins emerging as one of the best go-to options in the league, it gives you a little more leeway with the players around him . However, Gay is proving to be a legitimate second wheel in this league.
As far as why we struggle with Cousins out....
We are a 8th seed contending team. We'll be fighting for that final playoff spot and likely fall in the 9-10 range. That should be an easy indicator that this team and roster is not done. We still have holes that need to be filled before we leap into contention talks. Once the roster is complete and we have consistent and complimentary pieces all around, I'm sure if Cousins were to go down we would remain competitive and win games.
Cousins' talent hides/patches a lot of the weaknesses of this team when he plays. When he doesn't, those weakness are on full display. If you continue to round out the roster and take care of those weaknesses with moves and transactions, you won't see such a steep dropoff in the level of play when Cousins is sitting on the bench.