2019 NBA All-Star Weekend Events (merged)

Do you watch all of the All-Star Weekend events?

  • Total voters
    26
Npliam said:
You really think the guy that is the 3rd option on a great team is more deserving than the guy that has defensive game plan drawn up to stop him every night?
Click to expand...
That's an interesting way to choose to interpret what I said. A more accurate interpretation would be that I think the #1 option on a .558 team should be selected over the #1 option on a .490 team.

I don't really think that "deserve" has anything to do with it: nobody "deserves" to be an All-Star. Donovan Mitchell earned an All-Star selection, so did Klay Thompson, IMO. Thompson got it, and Mitchell didn't. Them's the breaks.


I guess such is life playing in a small market. Its no wonder that all the stars try to get to bigger markets.
Click to expand...
Man, get off this "woe is me/nobody respects us" stuff. Every one of the western reserves except for Thompson plays in a small media market. Don't blame Mitchell's snub on "market."
 
Turgenev said:
Obviously someone misses out - but I think DeMar DeRozen was a bit unlucky.

Since the game is no longer East vs West I don't think that the player selection should be confined to a set number from each conference.
Click to expand...

You can't snub the East fan base by not including an equal number of players from their conference.
 
Npliam said:
You really think the guy that is the 3rd option on a great team is more deserving than the guy that has defensive game plan drawn up to stop him every night?

Klay almost never sees a double team. He is 3rd on the scouting report and the other 2 are sure fire hall of famers that may be the best to ever play their positions offensively. IS he a good player? Sure. Could he be an All Star? Sure. Is he more deserving that Donovan? No way.
Click to expand...

While I agree on all your points about Klay, if Donovan Mitchell has a case then why wouldn't De'Aaron Fox?

Mitchell is scoring nearly 5 more points per game, but Fox averages over 3 more assists, has better shooting percentages, PER and is also on a winning team, while being a focal point of defenses looking to slow the KINGS pace.

I think it could easily be argued that Fox has had a better season than Mitchell. Yet nobody is making a case that he was snubbed.
 
VF21 said:
You can't snub the East fan base by not including an equal number of players from their conference.
Click to expand...
It's a similar situation to the proposed top 16 teams playoffs structure to me. Teams, fan bases and players in the western conference face an uphill battle simply due to the conference structure and parity.
 
KingsFanSince85 said:
While I agree on all your points about Klay, if Donovan Mitchell has a case then why wouldn't De'Aaron Fox?

Mitchell is scoring nearly 5 more points per game, but Fox averages over 3 more assists, has better shooting percentages, PER and is also on a winning team, while being a focal point of defenses looking to slow the KINGS pace.

I think it could easily be argued that Fox has had a better season than Mitchell. Yet nobody is making a case that he was snubbed.
Click to expand...

Because he's not and neither in Mitchell. I don't think Gobert is worthy either. All of these guys are borderline all-stars but borderline isn't good enough when there are only 12 spots.

As slim said, that's the breaks.

If Gobert and Mitchell wanted to be all-stars they should have won more. Gobert talks like he is on great top-tier team yet their record is only 30-24.
 
sergmatt said:
Because he's not and neither in Mitchell.
Click to expand...

I agree. Just making the point since he only seemed to be considering Mitchell.

sergmatt said:
I don't think Gobert is worthy either.
Click to expand...

I've been hard on Gobert over the years because I largely believe him to be overrated. But in this case, I do think he was a much bigger snub. I wouldn't have had a problem had he made it.

sergmatt said:
All of these guys are borderline all-stars but borderline isn't good enough when there are only 12 spots.

As slim said, that's the breaks.

If Gobert and Mitchell wanted to be all-stars they should have won more. Gobert talks like he is on great top-tier team yet their record is only 30-24.
Click to expand...

Agree on all these points.

Also, every year someone has a case. It's the way of the NBA. In the past it's been Damien Lillard. Now that he's on, it's someone else. There's no way around it unless they increase the roster size (which then lessens the meaning of making the team).
 
Klay and Towns is not more deserving than DeRozan or Gobert or Harris.

Klay is way over rated. Hope heaves the worries so we can see what he can do away from Curry and Durant
 
kingsfan1984 said:
Klay and Towns is not more deserving than DeRozan or Gobert or Harris.

Klay is way over rated. Hope heaves the worries so we can see what he can do away from Curry and Durant
Click to expand...

Hope heaves the worries! If this is an auto-correct, it's awesome. If it's not an auto-correct, I have no idea what you mean... but it's still awesome.
 
It's not even that Mitchell and Gobert don't "deserve" to be All-Stars, if you continue to insist on that particular term. It's just that they don't inherently "deserve" it more than anybody else.
 
If there was a cap on number of players eligible for the all-star game from a single team each season- to say ... 2 - then maybe there would be less super teams and more players willing to play for smaller markets. Also could be cool if the host city automatically had one of their players selected as a starter (or captain) - just like the world cup.
 
Turgenev said:
If there was a cap on number of players eligible for the all-star game from a single team each season- to say ... 2 - then maybe there would be less super teams and more players willing to play for smaller markets. Also could be cool if the host city automatically had one of their players selected as a starter (or captain) - just like the world cup.
Click to expand...

I don't follow your logic completely. Limiting the number of all-stars from a single team is interesting. I don't think it would lead to fewer super teams and more players willing to play for smaller markets, however. Top tier players don't sign with teams to be all-stars. They sign with teams to win championships.
 
Turgenev said:
If there was a cap on number of players eligible for the all-star game from a single team each season- to say ... 2 - then maybe there would be less super teams and more players willing to play for smaller markets...
Click to expand...
You know what really helps motivate players to play/stay in smaller markets? Competence.
 
VF21 said:
I don't follow your logic completely. Limiting the number of all-stars from a single team is interesting. I don't think it would lead to fewer super teams and more players willing to play for smaller markets, however. Top tier players don't sign with teams to be all-stars. They sign with teams to win championships.
Click to expand...

Some top players may not join a team with two established stars if it meant they could not participate in the all star game. Some players will still join - and be willing to sacrifice an appearance just as others have been willing to sacrifice salary. Similarly, there may be some teams less willing to embrace new talent if it impaired their ability to make the all star team. For example - if there was a two all star limit - would GS be willing to welcome KD if it meant that neither Klay nor Green had any chance of making the ASG (and had AS salary incentive in their contracts)? It's not a complete solution - but disincentive nonetheless.
 
Last edited:
Mr. S£im Citrus said:
You know what really helps motivate players to play/stay in smaller markets? Competence.
Click to expand...

Competence is not the sole predictor (and you know this right?). Examples: Kawhi leaving SA, Gordon Hayward leaving Utah. Nor is the interaction between an organisations 'competence' and a star players desires a one way street... And nothing about my comment suggested teams had license to be incompetent while remaining entitled to star players... Anyway. I offered a thought. Others can choose to think about it or dismiss it and the world will still turn...
 
Last edited:
Turgenev said:
Competence is not the sole predictor (and you know this right?). Examples: Kawhi leaving SA, Gordon Hayward leaving Utah.
Click to expand...
Poor examples. Leonard and Hayward wanted out of San Antonio and Utah, respectively, because they both felt done wrong by the organization. And, objectively, they were both right. Had the Spurs not handled Leonard's injury the way they did, and had Utah showed Hayward the money, rather than make a statement saying that they were going to wait to see if he earned it, they're both still playing for the teams they started on.

Nor is the interaction between an organisations 'competence' and a star players desires a one way street...
Click to expand...
I mean, I guess, but there aren't really any examples of players leaving competent small markets, when there wasn't some other form of breakdown in the relationship between the player and management.
  • The only real example I can think of for a star player leaving a competent small market is Kevin Durant, and your "two All-Star limit" suggestion wouldn't have done anything to stop that from happening.
  • To say nothing of the fact that you could make the argument that there aren't twelve competent franchises in the NBA right now, depending on what your threshold for "competence" happens to be... Which means that a "two All-Star limit" could force an All-Star player to sign with an 'incompetent' franchise, which is just another way of rewarding franchises for being incompetent. I'm not here for any of that.
  • Finally, what happens when you have a situation like the Warriors, when they had four All-Stars last year, but they drafted three of them? In that case, a "two All-Star limit" penalizes a team for being competent.

Anyway. I offered a thought.
Click to expand...
And I offered a thought on your thought. So... where are we now?
 
Turgenev said:
Some top players may not join a team with two established stars if it meant they could not participate in the all star game. Some players will still join - and be willing to sacrifice an appearance just as others have been willing to sacrifice salary. Similarly, there may be some teams less willing to embrace new talent if it impaired their ability to make the all star team. For example - if there was a two all star limit - would GS be willing to welcome KD if it meant that neither Klay nor Green had any chance of making the ASG (and had AS salary incentive in their contracts)? It's not a complete solution - but disincentive nonetheless.
Click to expand...

You're assuming facts not in evidence.
 
I’ll just say I despise everything about NBA All-Star Weekend. I think I’d rather watch the Pro Bowl.
 
kingsboi said:
so you won't watch Buddy in the three point and Fox in the Skills and Bagley in the Rising Stars?
Click to expand...

I MIGHT be tempted to watch the 3 point shootout.

Skills and dunk are terrible, and I’m not watching a second of either of the “Games” held. Bagley will likley have some sweet sweet highlight dunks to check out after though.
 
SLAB said:
I MIGHT be tempted to watch the 3 point shootout.

Skills and dunk are terrible, and I’m not watching a second of either of the “Games” held. Bagley will likley have some sweet sweet highlight dunks to check out after though.
Click to expand...

when was the last time you watched an entire All-Star weekend?
 
kingsboi said:
when was the last time you watched an entire All-Star weekend?
Click to expand...

It’s been a long time. I haven’t watched the actual all-star game in years... the other game probably not since rookie/sophomore.

I WAS stoked when Boogie was in the Skills comp.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

I
USA for the Gold Medals
Replies
2
Views
886
hrdboild
hrdboild
sactowndog
40 players in Olympic pool (Only one King)
Replies
7
Views
936
jellyfish
J
VF21
2019 Free Agency tracking thread
7 8 9
Replies
258
Views
18K
Kingster
Kingster
Y
Kobe maintains huge lead in 2nd round of NBA All-Star voting (Ball Don't Lie)
Replies
0
Views
367
Yahoo! Sports - NBA -
Y
Mr. S£im Citrus
[FIBA] Cousins, Gay among thirty finalists for Rio
Replies
16
Views
7K
lwc
lwc
Back
Top