That's a harsher assessment than I would have expected. I'll admit I've only seen a very little of Whiteside, but what I've seen looks like another Marcus Camby (even if you have to wait a few years) and I don't think I see 14 guys I'd take in front of that. But maybe you've seen motivational issues in Whiteside that knock him down in your eyes?
Its just my opinion. That doesn't make it fact. I've seen Whiteside play less than most of the top prospects. Mostly because Marshall just wasn't on that many times. But I've seen him at least six times including his conference tourney. He got outplayed by Jerome Jordan in his final game. At least in my opinion. Since I didn't have a very high opinion of Jordan at the time, that didn't bode well for me.
Its not that I don't think he has long range potential. He does. But as Vince Lombardi said, Potential means you haven't done anything yet. Its possible that someone will take a flyer on him in the lottery. Just like Memphis did last year with Thabeet. But your not going to get any immediate help from him in the way of serious minutes.
I just think that there are players that are more skilled and more NBA ready that I would take ahead of him. If I had the 10th choice in the draft and I had to choose between him and Udoh, I would take Udoh. Whiteside may have more upside because of his athleticism. But so did Gerold Green, and Tyrus Thomas. If I had to choose between Whiteside and Aldrich, once again I would take Aldrich. Both Aldrich and Udoh are more NBA ready. I think both can step in and contribute now.
When you throw in the fact that Whiteside has had problems with immaturity and is also having problems accademicly, I think you have to raise a red flag. Unlike Cousins, who is much more skilled, and has similar things said about him, but has so far proven the critic's wrong, Whiteside's problems have gotten worse. I'm williing to overlook some of these things in a player of Cousins caliber, but not on a player whose a risk on both the immaturity and the skill level front.
I'm sure there are a lot of people that would disagree with me and thats fine. I've been wrong before. I just don't think the Kings are in a position to take to many risks right now. A team like the Spurs or the Mav's would be a perfect fit for him. Yeah, I know, the vision of him playing in an all star game in a few years dances through your head while you kick yourself. Always a possibility. Now if we could get the Timberwolves to cough up one of their three first round picks for a reasonable price, then I'd be willing to take the gamble.