Bee: 31 scariest moments in sports history

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
#1
http://www.sacbee.com/100/story/69236.html

The 31 scariest moments in sports history
Fights, bites and sights-prepare to be horrified
By Joe Davidson - Bee Staff Writer
Last Updated 12:04 pm PST Tuesday, October 31, 2006


Fright night doesn't just happen on Halloween. Not in sports.

Unpredictability, shock, the extraordinary -- all are part of the allure of athletics. And some things that happen on playing fields, courts, tracks, and in rings and rinks are plain scary.

Some are just results of a heightened version of regular facets of a game: a jarring tackle or a slip and fall on the ice, maybe an epic car crash during a race.

Then there are those things that come out of nowhere: boxer Mike Tyson biting a chunk out of an opponent's ear; pitcher Juan Marichal using a bat to vent his rage on another player; a basketball fight that nearly kills a man.

Those are images and moments that jerk observers forward in their seats, making jaws drop. But they also become more, imprinting themselves on memories and etching their drama into the tablets of sporting lore.

They can be so intense that they are hard to watch -- did someone mention Joe Theismann? -- but even people who shield their eyes might peek through their fingers at the replay, so remarkable is the scene.

It's a part of sports that's tough to resist. We watch to see the achievement -- and because we know that what unfolds could be something unforgettable, even if it sends chills up our backs.

October's 31 days are capped by the spookiness of Halloween, and The Bee came up with 31 haunting sports moments. It's not meant to be the definitive list but rather a compendium of milestones that have become part of our ongoing sports conversation, entries in the book of "You remember when ... ?"

Note: These are presented in no particular order and were chosen based on the enduring presence they have maintained in the collective sports consciousness.

Here's a look:

1. 1985: Joe Theismann's leg

Joe Theismann's career comes to a horrific end on "Monday Night Football" when Giants linebacker Lawrence Taylor sacks the Washington Redskins quarterback and rolls onto the back of his lower leg, breaking it. Taylor immediately pleads for sideline help for Theismann, laying on the turf in agony. Redskins lineman Russ Grimm later says the scene was the "most disgusting thing I've ever seen."

2. 1970: "The Agony of Defeat"

The name Vinko Bogataj might not be familiar, but his spectacular crash and burn in the 1970 International Ski Flying Championship in Germany surely is. It is the signature image for ABC's "Wide World of Sports" opening montage. In it, Bogataj loses control and tumbles off the side of the jump ramp, plowing through a fence near stunned spectators. The accident looks fatal, but Bogataj suffers only a concussion.

3. 2004: Basket-brawl

When NBA rivals Indiana and Detroit get into it late in a regular-season game, the real stomach-turner comes in the fight's aftermath: fans throwing objects; players throwing punches; fans swinging back.

And a national TV audience cursing the product.

League record fines and suspensions are the result, as well as a black eye on player and fan behavior.

4. 1989: Malarchuk slashed

It seems like a routine NHL collision until Buffalo Sabres goalie Clint Malarchuk nearly dies on the ice. During a game against the St. Louis Blues, he is sliced across the jugular by Steve Tuttle's skate blade, which got into the exposed area below Malarchuk's mask.

Blood pools and freezes on the ice. Fearing he would die, Malarchuk asks for his mother to be called, as well as for a priest. Two fans in the arena suffer heart attacks, and teammates are physically sickened by the spectacle.

Malarchuk has 300 stitches, survives and plays again, and the NHL rules that goalies must wear neck protectors.

5. 1988: "The King" flips

Known as "The King" for his flair and impressive stock car racing résumé, Richard Petty becomes the central figure of one of the sport's biggest "Oh, my!" moments when on Lap 106 of the Daytona 500, his car slides sideways, goes airborne, repeatedly flips along the guardrail after hitting the ground, then is hit by another car. Remarkably, Petty walks away from the crash, having temporarily lost his sight because of the excessive G-forces he experienced.

Had Petty worn his trademark cowboy hat, the brim might have been frayed by this one. But not the driver.

6. 1965: Marichal attacks

While batting in a game during a tight pennant race, Giants pitcher Juan Marichal wheels on Dodgers catcher John Roseboro and smashes him on the head with his bat. Marichal claims Roseboro grazed his ear when making a return throw to pitcher Sandy Koufax and that the bat attack was a response to that.

Years later, Marichal wonders if Hall of Fame voters hold the incident against him and asks Roseboro to forgive him. Roseboro does, and in 1983, Marichal is elected to the Hall of Fame.

7. 1977: A devastating punch

Trying to restore order in a game between his Houston Rockets and Los Angeles Lakers, Rudy Tomjanovich runs toward fighting players and is floored by a punch from brawny Lakers forward Kermit Washington. "Rudy T" asks trainers, "Did the scoreboard fall on me?" before passing out, soaked in his own blood and suffering from multiple skull fractures. He recovers to play again and, later, to coach. Washington repeatedly apologizes and is convinced the punch has kept him from meaningful NBA employment.

8. 2003: Stevens is trampled

Hall of Fame jockey Gary Stevens is heading for victory in the Arlington Million when his mount, Storming Home, veers to the right and dumps Stevens in the path of onrushing thoroughbreds. One horse steps on Stevens' chest, another clips his ear with a hoof, and the jockey is bounced around like a rag doll. He later admits he thought death was imminent. About a month later, he is riding again, despite having suffered a collapsed lung, compressed vertebra and assorted bumps, bruises and scratches. Storming Home, by the way, is disqualified.

9. 1997: Tyson's bite night

Outraged and later claiming Evander Holyfield was head-butting, Mike Tyson bit off a chunk of the heavyweight champion's right ear, then bit the left. After losing the fight, Tyson points to his swollen eye, allegedly caused by Holyfield head butts, and protests, "Look at me, man. Look at me. I've got to go home, and my kids are going to be scared of me now!"

10. 1988: Reynolds down

Who can blame Jerry Reynolds for taking a quick nap? The Kings are terrible, plodding along at 5-18 when Reynolds, the Kings' coach, collapses in front of the scorer's table during a game against the Portland Trail Blazers. He lies unconscious, leaving thousands at Arco Arena frantic about the fan favorite. Turns out his fainting spell is caused by exhaustion and a sudden change of posture on the sideline.

It is an unfunny moment for a man renowned for his humor.

These are the 21 other events that fill out the Scary 31.

11. 1978: Stingley paralyzed

Fans remember the horrific hit on New England receiver Darryl Stingley by former Raiders great Jack Tatum, the self-anointed "Assassin," and Tatum's lack of remorse over the decades.

12. 1990: Gathers dies on court

Hank Gathers, all smiles and points as an All-American for Loyola Marymount, collapses during a game his senior season. Surrounded by horrified teammates, he dies from a heart defect.

13. 1972: Nightmare in Munich

The Olympic spirit is shattered when 11 Israeli athletes are killed by terrorists, leaving ABC sports announcer Jim McKay to announce, "They're gone. They're all gone."

14. 1989: Dravecky goes down

Giants pitcher Dave Dravecky is the year's feel-good story, coming back from cancer in his arm. But the arm breaks when delivering a pitch, contributing to the end of Dravecky's career. His arm later is amputated.

15. 2001: Zanardi loses his legs

CART driver Alex Zanardi has both legs amputated after he is hit at high speed during a race in Germany. He survives the ordeal.

16. 1957: Score's career ruined

Yankees infielder Gil McDougal smashes a line drive into Cleveland pitcher Herb Score's face. Score recovers, but the left-hander's promising career is never the same.

17. 1989: Shameful fight night

It looks like a European soccer match has been plopped into the middle of Arco Arena when fans riot after Juan "John John" Molina beats local favorite Tony Lopez.

18. 2004: Skater's face-first landing

Pairs ice skater Tatiana Totmianina is dropped by partner Maxim Marinin and falls face-first in a Skate America competition. Totmianina recovers, and she and Marinin win gold in the 2006 Turin Olympics in their final amateur performance.

19. 2004: Bertuzzi clobbers Moore

Even in the rough-and-tumble NHL, Todd Bertuzzi's brutal from-behind hit that left Steve Moore with a broken neck defies belief. Even hockey goons wince.

20. 1989: Krumrie's bad break

In a ghastly Super Bowl XXIII moment, Cincinnati nose tackle Tim Krumrie plants a cleat in the turf as his body is twisted, snapping his leg in two places against the 49ers.

21. 1993: Seles stabbing

A deranged fan in Hamburg, Germany, gets behind tennis star Monica Seles and stabs her in the back during a quarterfinal match changeover. Seles later wins another Grand Slam singles title.

22. 1994: McCallum's career-ender

Raiders running back Napoleon McCallum is tangled in a pileup against the 49ers, breaking his leg and rupturing an artery. He survives but never plays again.

23. 1967: 'Tony C' beaned

If the pitch from the Angels' Jack Hamilton that crushed Tony Conigliaro's eye socket does not make one recoil, it's the subsequent image of the Red Sox outfielder's battered face that does. Altered both careers.

24. 2000: McSorley levels Brashear

Boston's Marty McSorley enhances his NHL goon image with his attack on Vancouver's Donald Brashear. McSorley still wonders what the big deal is.

25. 1994: Kerrigan attacked

Olympic skating takes a dark turn when Tonya Harding's thug friends club Nancy Kerrigan's leg in an effort to knock her out of Olympic competition. Kerrigan recovers, but Harding remains a target for one-liners.

26. 2004: Full-contact tennis

During a practice session in Rome, James Blake races to the net to return a drop shot, loses his balance and breaks his neck when he slams head-first into a post. He returns within months and later achieves a top-10 ranking.

27. 1988: Louganis hits head

In the Seoul Olympics, the world's best diver -- Greg Louganis -- hits his head on the board in the three-meter competition, falling unconscious into the pool. With stitches, he wins gold days later.

28. 1987: Jim greets Joe

Joe Montana is knocked out of a playoff game on a thundering hit by Giants lineman Jim Burt. Montana says it is the worst hit of his career.

29. 1970: Rose plows Fosse

Pete Rose always played hard. Catcher Ray Fosse finds that out when he tries to block the plate during the All-Star Game. Rose runs through Fosse to score, and the injured Fosse's career goes downhill.

30. 1999: Stewart's strange demise

U.S. Open golf champion Payne Stewart and five associates die when their Learjet loses cabin pressure. The aircraft flies on autopilot until running out of fuel and crashing in South Dakota.

31. 2003: Webber's knee goes

Kings All-Star forward Chris Webber blows out his knee in the second game of the NBA Western Conference semifinals against Dallas. The injury signaled a downward spiral for the Kings.
 

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
#2
I'd also try and find a place for Wllis McGahee's injury in the 2003 Fiesta Bowl. Anyone who saw that game had to wonder if McGahee would ever be able to play again. One of the most horrific knee injuries I've ever seen.
 

pdxKingsFan

So Ordinary That It's Truly Quite Extraordinary
Staff member
#3
The first thing that sprung to mind was Theismann but Malarchuk's was 100 times worse and should be #1, #2 if you account for the fact that more people saw Theismann. But there's no reason to have anything else above it, especially not the basketbrawl.

Tony C, Seles and Kerrigan also belong in the top 10.
 

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
#4
They aren't in any particular order...

Note: These are presented in no particular order and were chosen based on the enduring presence they have maintained in the collective sports consciousness.
 
#6
A few omissions that the Bee writer should have included:

(1.) In 1920, Carl Mays, a New York Giants pitcher, beans a player with a pitch, though I can't remember the hitter's name. But the batter later dies in a N.Y. hospital the next day, and becomes baseball's first and only on-field casualty.

(2.) #11 mentioned the Darryl Stingley incident. But wasn't there a Philly Eagles player who was later paralyzed after a game? I don't remember his name but it took place sometime in the late 80's or early 90's. I remember this happened when future Football Hall of Famer Reggie White was with the Eagles.

(3.) Actually more eerie than scary, but I would also include the moments right before Game #3 of the 1989 World Series. The Loma Prieta Earthquake.

(4.) Detroit Tiger Ty Cobb chases a fan under the stands and beats him up right in the middle of a game. Cobb was suspended indefinitely and his Tigers teammates supported him by going AWOL the next day. The team owner had to recruit college players and sandlot players for one day. Cobb's suspension was reduced down to eight days.

(5.) 2004 Summer Olympics. A defrocked Irish Catholic priest named Neil Horan bursts out of the crowd and restrains a Brazilian marathon runner who was leading the race and possibly might've won if the ex-priest hadn't pushed him off into the crowd. It turned out that the priest was holding a sign saying that the "end of the world is near". He also had a previous history of disrupting other high-profile sporting events.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neil_Horan
 
#7
I'd add Cisse's leg break. Scary thing is that it happened twice. The most recent one against China in a friendy game right before World Cup.

1st time:


2nd time:
 
Last edited:

pdxKingsFan

So Ordinary That It's Truly Quite Extraordinary
Staff member
#8
That marathon incident was so sad as the runner was a feel good story up until that point (he was breaking down though).

Fan man was pretty crazy if you think about the potential for all the things that could have gone wrong with that stunt, plus modern day terrorist concerns.

Rollen Stewart (Rainbow Man/John 3:16 guy) also went nuts and took a hostage in the early 90s, not at a sporting event though.
 
#9
Thanks vj... now I have room for more pie.

Theissman deserves to be #1 in my mind because of the sheer gruesomeness and the multiple replays during prime time.

Dave Busst would have made the list in any soccer-loving country (as well as Cisse).

Hard to believe Maurice Stokes was not mentioned.
~~
 

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
#11
Was it Bryant Young who had somebody's helmet crash into and shatter/invert his lower leg in a game?

Also, ditto for Stephon Marbury's noggin doing the big grotesque to Jayson Williams' leg to pretty much end his career.
 
#12
Was it Bryant Young who had somebody's helmet crash into and shatter/invert his lower leg in a game?

Yes. It was Ken Norton Jrs. helmet!

I think the collapse and convulsing death of National League umpire John McSherry should make the list.

The broken leg and subsequent euthenasia of "Ruffian" and many other racehorses could qualify.

My first thought was Tony C and then Dave Dravecki.
 

pdxKingsFan

So Ordinary That It's Truly Quite Extraordinary
Staff member
#13
I think the collapse and convulsing death of National League umpire John McSherry should make the list.
Good one. Along with Marge Schott crying and screaming after the game that this fat overweight umpire had to ruin her opening day by dying on her.
 
#14
Good one. Along with Marge Schott crying and screaming after the game that this fat overweight umpire had to ruin her opening day by dying on her.
And along with the crowd booing and protesting because the game was immediately cancelled as a result of someone dropping dead on the field.
 

pdxKingsFan

So Ordinary That It's Truly Quite Extraordinary
Staff member
#15
I might be willing to cut the crowd some slack because those booing may not have recognized what was happening - I honestly don't know as I didn't recall the crowd's reaction, just ESPN shamelessly replaying the collapse multiple times that afternoon. Marge on the other hand had all the information and was a representative of the league.

This does bring to mind another incident - the in ring death of Owen Hart and Vince McMahon's decision to continue the event.
 
#18
Malarchuk was sick.

McGahee's injury was also brutal. I remember seeing it and wondering and being astounded it was still attached.

Even though it was wrestling, Sid breaking his foot still makes me cringe a little.
 
#19
Hard to believe Maurice Stokes was not mentioned.~~
I thought of Stokes too. Maybe it was because people didn't realize how serious it was at the moment it happend. Stokes and Twyman are two of the retired Royals/Kings jerseys. Great story of friendship.

In the 1950s, his ability to beat opponents to rebounds with his muscular body, quickness and positioning was nearly unparalleled. He averaged more than 20 rebounds per game in college, more than 17 in the NBA. He passed well, too, good enough to be among the NBA's assist leaders, and averaged double figures in scoring.

Maurice Stokes was one of basketball's best forwards then, one of its least-known stars now. Stokes, 6-foot-7 and 240 pounds, wasn't around long enough to be remembered like many of his peers. In the final regular-season game of the 1957-58 season, his third year as a pro, the Cincinnati Royals all-star fell to the floor, hit his head and was knocked unconscious.

Three days later, the 24-year-old went into a coma and was permanently paralyzed, his career over. His life, however, wasn't over, thanks mostly to teammate Jack Twyman, who helped to raise money for his medical expenses and became his legal guardian.

Twyman started an exhibition game in Stokes' honor and established the Maurice Stokes Foundation to defray hospital costs.

In 1973, three years after Stokes' death, his story was told in the film "Maurie," which starred former football player Bernie Casey. Though few of today's NBA stars know much about Stokes, mid-century players appreciated his game. Bobby Wanzer, who coached and played with him, said, "If things had worked out differently, Maurice would have become one of the top 10 players of all time."

Said Twyman: "No one had seen a guy with that combination of strength, speed and size."