We have no way of knowing what trades were available. Totally agree. I just wanted to give my take on how I would have approached the offseason. I think it's fair to say that I could have worded some of that better to make it seem like not everything was 100% on the table.
If nobody was looking to make a deal for #4 or let's just say nobody was willing to make any trades with us for any player (Barnes, Holmes, etc.), I would have...
- Drafted Keegan Murray at #4
- Drafted EJ Liddell at #37
- Drafted Keon Ellis at #49 (didn't know who Sasha was so not going to pretend like I did)
- Extended a qualifying offer to Donte DiVincenzo & matched him up to a deal similar to Holmes
That would have left us with a roster of...
PG - Fox / Mitchell
SG - DiVincenzo / Davis / Ellis
SF - Barnes / Holiday / Harkless
PF - Murray / Lyles / Liddell / Metu
C - Sabonis / Holmes / Len
...while still having ownership over all of our future picks and ~$40 mil in cap space next offseason with Fox, Mitchell, DiVincenzo, Ellis, Murray, Liddell, Sabonis, Holmes, & 2023 SAC 1st under contract. DiVincenzo would have at least given us one reliable defender in the starting unit. Fox is below average, Barnes is below average to average, Sabonis is below average, and Murray will hopefully be good one day but not many rookies are good defenders right out of the gate.
As I've said before and I'll say again, I don't think the moves McNair made are bad value. He didn't massively overpay Monk or sell the farm to land Huerter. What I do criticize is the vision he has for this team (e.g., offense & shooting with little regard to defense) and the constraint on our flexibility with how our 1st round picks are tied up now. I wouldn't have made the deals he made because it appears that we have stark differences on what you need to be a winning team in this league.
The X factor here is Brown. If Brown can take this collection of below average to average defenders that McNair has assembled and turn them into an average defensive team, then he's worth his weight in gold.