J-Will was a far better talent. Was a J-Will a superstar? Lonzo has major issues that did not show up in the box score but obvious to astute observer. He was playing against trash competition. His defense is terrible. His effort is not good. His defense is predicated on taking chances. He goes under every screen and gives the guard free reign. He may get away with that against the G-Leaguers. He is not going to get away with that against George Hill or Chris Paul. My thing on guys I don't like like Tatum and Lonzo is that if you make your shot you are going to be okay. He made his shot last night. Wide open and uncontested. And he got hot. Credit to him. And the lay-up and an one was a nice finish against a 6'1" defender. It was pick-up rec league garbage time basketball and he excelled.
Lonzo has an obvious knack for throw ahead passes a la Kevin Love. And Ricky Rubio. Is Ricky Rubio a superstar? To be a superstar you cannot have holes in your game. This guy is a bad defender (poor effort AND lateral mobility and physicality). He has weak on-one-one moves to breakdown a defender. He has no in between game (no floater, no pull-up jumper). He doesn't finish particularly strong at the rim. He doesn't draw contact. His shot is not trustworthy. These are ALL traits you have to have to be a star let alone superstar. Now is he going to overcome all these deficiencies and become the superstar you expect him to be. Well anything is possible, I suppose, after all, Papa G went for 17/13 last night.
But I would not bet on Lonzo Ball being anything more than a really good passer, a below average defender, and a spotty scorer. The traits are just not there in terms of hustle, competitiveness, and athleticism to equate into a superstar. You cannot be a superstar based on one skill (passing).