You seem to be experiencing a few concept errors:
- There's no question that acquiring Gay was a good trade, but my push back would be that you're incorrect on why it was a good trade, or even why the trade was made. Your suggestion that Evans was traded, and Gay acquired in order to free up the paint for Cousins is not supported by the fact that a full quarter of the season was played after Evans was traded, and before Gay was traded for, that appeared to have no impact on whether Cousins operated from the elbow or not. Who was keeping Cousins out of the paint the first twenty games of last season, such that we needed to trade for Gay to correct it? Patrick Patterson? Chuck Hayes? The Gay trade was a good trade because he was the best player we could have gotten back for the players we needed to get rid of, but your understanding of the motives behind the trade is flawed.
- You are seriously misremembering both the pre-draft scouting reports on Ben McLemore, and the post-draft analysis. That kid was absolutely not drafted to be a '3 and D' guy; he was drafted because he was BPA, and because he was considered to have the most upside of any player in the draft. McLemore has been beginning to develop into a 3 and D guy because of Malone's influence, not because of that's what he was drafted for.
- Better defender does not equal good defender. Darren Collison is a better defender than Isaiah Thomas, but so are a lot of other point guards in the NBA. Collison is a more disciplined point guard than Thomas, but there's no part of his game that says controlled and deliberate; he wants to push the ball as much, if not more, than anyone else on the team.
- And let's not overlook his other actions that don't support your theory giving up Lopez for nothing in the Evans trade. Not making a serious bid for Iguodala. Trading Mbah a Moute for the positionless Williams. Signing Landry. D'Alessandro either whiffed on or flat gave up a lot of Malone flavored guys, for several guys who are not.
I actually agree with a lot of the points you bring up, but I don't think it fundamentally changes the fact that the starting 5 assembled by PDA is clearly one that plays best at a slow, deliberate style.
As to your points:
1- I agree that the Tyreke trade being a set-up for Gay is mostly speculation, but I think it's supported by the evidence that we have. First, we know it was PDA's goal from Day 1 to acquire Gay. Second, we know that PDA has a good relationship with Masai, so it's very reasonable to think that they discussed the contours of a possible trade, and what assets Masai was looking for, from day one and on an ongoing basis. Third, it doesn't mean much that GV played here for a while. He was shipped out pretty much the moment the Kings were allowed to trade him, so it's not a stretch to think TOR-SAC had agreed in principle to the framework of a trade that they had to wait to execute due to NBA trade rules.
I agree that it would've been great to get Lopez. I don't know why we let him go to PDX for basically nothing, so I'll give you that point.
2- the scouting report on BMac was excellent shooter with freakishly high athleticism. That's generally how you describe all 3 and D players.
EDIT: also agree that MM did a fantastic job developing and managing BMac. I'm not trying to trash Malone, I'm arguing that PDA has done a better job than were giving him credit for.
3- I agree. DC is not a perfect PG but he is better suited to a half-court hard-nosed defensive team than IT was. Which is exactly my point.
4- Iggy I'll give you, how PDA handled that pissed me off. But it's obvious he got wind that Iggy was playing us for leverage against GSW (or at least PDA thought it was), so the offer-pull wasn't reflective of PDA's basketball philosophy. You also have to admit that if you think Iggy fits the Malone philosophy, then PDA offering Iggy a contract is evidence if PDA and MM being on the same page.
I addressed DWill above. That was a pretty marginal move in terms of team impact, and I think it was more about managing trade assets than anything. And Luc really isn't the caliber of player to lose sleep over, anyways