The main problem I see with Williams when he's on the floor is that his confidence wavers. When he's on he's got a solid outside jumper, the ability to post up and finish inside, good effort on the boards, and like McLemore he's always a threat on the fast break. He's also got the right size and athletic profile to defend anyone at the SF position. He's not elite in any one area, but he doesn't really have any holes in his game either. Trouble is he seems too comfortable deferring to other players. It was the same story in college really, he was just so much more talented than everyone else on the team that they made an effort to find him with the ball anyway. Then you compound that lack of aggression with other small issues -- he's not consistent enough on his release for his jumper to be a reliable threat at this level, he's never shown any particular talent for using his ball skills to set up anyone else, his team defensive awareness needs work -- and he's just not prepared to be effective in a support role right now. These are fixable issues, and maybe that's where the question of motivation comes in. Entering his fourth year now, you'd hope he would have figured something out but he seems to be the same player that he was coming out of Arizona.
To be anything other than a garbage time All-Star in the NBA he's got to do one of two things (1) tighten up the skills necessary to settle into a backup role -- get that release point down, learn the offense and defensive schemes inside and out or (2) stop playing tentative and show that he can be a go-to option every night. We had a similar type of player here once upon a time with Gerald Wallace. Ultimately Wallace did figure it out, but he had to go to a last place team with a huge talent gap to do it. That probably would have been the best thing for Williams as well. I don't feel good about his chances of figuring this out backing up Rudy Gay, but it's up to him really.
To be anything other than a garbage time All-Star in the NBA he's got to do one of two things (1) tighten up the skills necessary to settle into a backup role -- get that release point down, learn the offense and defensive schemes inside and out or (2) stop playing tentative and show that he can be a go-to option every night. We had a similar type of player here once upon a time with Gerald Wallace. Ultimately Wallace did figure it out, but he had to go to a last place team with a huge talent gap to do it. That probably would have been the best thing for Williams as well. I don't feel good about his chances of figuring this out backing up Rudy Gay, but it's up to him really.