Look, a lot of people like Smart. So maybe there's something wrong with me. Believe me, I've tried to like him, and I've probably watched him play as much or more than anyone else in this draft. But I just don't see what all the hype is about. He's a decent athlete, but there's nothing special in that area. He doesn't have great hops. He's a good ballhandler, but again, he's no Tyreke Evans or even a Tony Wroten in that area. He's a good passer, but he doesn't blow me away with his creativity in setting up his teammates. He takes too many shots for a PG in my opinion, ( I don't like PG's that dominate the ball unless their Steve Nash or John Stockton clones) and he's just not a good shooter. I do think his shooting could improve if he would take the time to work on his form, and get squared up before shooting.
Defense is the one area where he's special. And, I'm not sure how much of his effectiveness will translate to the NBA. But its certainly a plus. My main objection to him is that we already had a player named Tyreke Evans that could do everything Smart can do and we didn't keep him. So I'll be just a little upset if we draft Smart after letting Tyreke go. If they didn't think Tyreke was a good fit for this team, then how is Smart a good fit? If they think IT shoots too much and doesn't look for his teammates enough, then how is Smart, who shoots too much a good fit?
I'll be honest. If my choice is between Ennis and Smart, I'd take Ennis. I know a lot of poeple will disagree with me. I also know that Ennis will never be the defensive player that Smart is, but I think you can make too big an issue of defense when judging the all around abilities of a player. Steve Nash is going to be in the HOF, and not many people have discussions about his defense. If a player is downright horrible on defense, thats a different story, and I realize that with Syracuse players its difficult to judge how good or bad they might be. But one thing I do know about Ennis, is that he's a very good PG in the strict sense of the word. And, he can at least hit the outside shot
Smart: 17.8 PPG - 42.5% FGP - 30.2% 3PP - 5.7 RPG - 4.7 APG - 2.8 Steals
Ennis: 12.4 PPG - 41.3% FGP - 37.1% 3PP - 3.4 RPG - 5.5 APG - 2.2 Steals
I realize that stats don't tell the whole story, but also remember, Syracuse is going to the big dance, and was ranked number one for a lot of the season with Ennis as the floor general. At the same time Oklahoma St. has struggled all year and is going to miss the tournament with Smart at the helm. Results matter! If Smart is such a great leader, why can't he lead his team into the tournament? Oklahoma has talent on that team. Enough talent to at least make the tournament. Hey, I could be dead wrong, and I'm willing to eat all the crow if I'am. Actually, I hope I'm wrong. I don't want to see any young player fail. But if he does fail, then I want it to be on someone else's team.