Desert Island Music Album Draft 2013 - draft complete

Should we extend the draft to 25 picks?


  • Total voters
    6
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

pdxKingsFan

So Ordinary That It's Truly Quite Extraordinary
Staff member
The stuff I really really hate I generally refrain from commenting on. Because at least I can say a few nice things even if they are back handed about LB.

Yeah, I am pretty sure I drafted another Metallica album with Puppets still on the table, but not totally sure because Spike was drafting up the good metal that go round. I consider them more like a 1a and 1b, I like the actual songs slightly better on the other album but Puppets just sounds better. Probably because Cliff was such an integral part of the band and they decided to make Jason's life a living hell, which is a damned shame. Anyone hear what he is doing now? Good stuff. Look forward to a full album.
 

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
Just a reminder: Discussing an album that has not yet been drafted is not in the spirit of the draft, even if you do not mention it by name.
 
The Olivia Tremor Control - Dusk at Cubist Castle (1996)

wiki

The Beatles on (way more) acid hop on a time machine, travel to the 90s and record and hour and change of psych-pop gems mixed with weird studio ramblings.
As original and entertaining as a 60s pop revival record can get.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Mr. S£im Citrus

Doryphore of KingsFans.com
Staff member
With the two hundred forty-sixth pick of the draft, Mr. Slim Citrus selects:




Jon B, Bonafide (1995)

I mentioned when I took Baduizm in the third round that it helped me to deal with the internal conflict I'd had, over a decision I'd made. Well, Bonafide is my personal soundtrack of that decision:

Two roads diverged in a yellow wood,
And sorry I could not travel both,
And be one traveller, long I stood.
And looked down one as far as I could,
to where it bent in the undergrowth.

Then took the other, just as fair,
And having perhaps the better claim,
Because it was grassy, and wanted wear.
Though, as for that, the passing there
had worn them really about the same.

And both that morning equally lay,
in leaves no steps had trodden black.
Oh, I kept the first for another day!
Yet, knowing how way leads on to way,
I doubted if I should ever come back.

I shall be telling this with a sigh,
somewhere ages and ages hence:
Two roads diverged in a wood, and I?
I took the one less traveled by.
And that has made all the difference.

When Ruth Deininger made my tenth grade English class memorize The Road Not Taken, I thought she was a sadist. Fast forward just about six years later, and I felt like this poem summarized my entire life. And, some seventeen years after the fact, I still can't think of any passage or verse that holds more significance to my life... with the possible exception of Bonafide.

But for a moment's hesitation, I found myself bound, not to the road less traveled, but to the other. So, back when my ex-wife was still my girlfriend, we'd had a fight, a fairly serious one, and we'd each ended up committing our own indiscretions. I knew that there was the potential for something real along the road less traveled, but I wasn't quite emotionally prepared to abandon ship in my first serious relationship. When the moment of truth came, she asked me, "What about your girlfriend?" I said, "Uhhh..." And, she said, "Wrong answer." And that was that. I went back to my girlfriend, we "forgave" each other our indiscretions, we got married, had a son, and were separated before his fourth birthday.

:: takes deep breaths, counts to ten ::

Anyway... Bonafide was Jon B's debut album, and his second-most commercially successful. Artistically, I tend to think that he peaked with this one, but I may be biased. The album only reached as high as Seventy-Nine on Billboard's Top 200, but it was certified Platinum. It did spawn two Top 25 singles, which turned out to be his second and third most popular songs, respectively: Someone to Love and Pretty Girl, both of which were co-produced by Babyface, the former of which earned Jon B his only Grammy nomination (cite: Wikipedia).


I still can't listen to "Gone Before Light" without getting emotional.
 
Last edited:

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
Okay, well I seem to have run out of inspiration for this pick. Nothing I am considering just screams must have to me, so I'm going to tick some boxes. First up, I have gone back and forth on whether to include anything from my hair metal roots, and finally why not. There were a couple of go big or go home sorts of picks left out there, but they sound dated to my new millennium ears, and so I am turning to an old favorite from the very end of the era which eschewed the cheese and spandex for some good straight ahead hard rock and roll:

Sonic Temple - The Cult (1989)


The grunge movement is appropriately credited with ending the hair metal era a few years later, but by 1989 there was already a new breed of hard rock bands popping up, headlined by GnR of course, that was turning its back on spandex and makeup and silly songs about banging underage groupies in the tour bus. The sound got cleaner, the songs more authentic. The Cult had already been around for a few years by the time they released this album, but when they did they instantly rocketed toward the top of the new hold-the-cheese hard rock sound. A number of the harder songs (Fire Woman, Sweet Soul Sister etc.) went on to become enduring hits, but my favorite song on the album, and one of my favorite ballads from the entire era was Edie (Ciao Baby), a tribute song to Andy Warhol muse Edie Sedgwick, who died of an overdose at age 28. I'm always a sucker for combining strings with hard rock.

Also:
Fire Woman: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Af1wuxRerV0
Sweet Soul Sister: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNobN73F2JY
 
Last edited by a moderator:
with the eighth pick in the 16th round of the 2013 Desert Island Music Draft, i select...

dredg - The Pariah, the Parrot, the Delusion (06/09/09):



01 Pariah
02 Drunk Slide
03 Ireland
04 Stamp of Origin: Pessimistic
05 Lightswitch
06 Gathering Pebbles
07 Information
08 Stamp of Origin: Ocean Meets Bay
09 Saviour
10 R U O K?
11 I Don't Know
12 Mourning this Morning
13 Stamp of Origin: Take a Look Around
14 Long Days and Vague Clues
15 Cartoon Showroom
16 Quotes
17 Down to the Cellar
18 Stamp of Origin: Horizon

Genre: alternative metal, art rock, progressive rock

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pariah,_the_Parrot,_the_Delusion


dredg is another band i discovered in high school, and while my freshman and sophomore years were replete with post-punk, new wave, and other 80's alternative discoveries, my junior and senior years were about looking forward. i wanted to find bands of my era that moved me, that managed to speak to the sensibilities i was forming. like many picks in this draft, i happened upon dredg because of the Deftones. dredg were the opening act during the 'tones '04 fall tour, and i arrived at the Grand in San Francisco just in time to catch their urgent, arresting performance. as a drummer, i was particularly impressed by the man behind the kit, Dino Campanella, who has since slotted himself in second place on my all-time favorite drummers list (headlined by Deftones' Abe Cunningham, and also featuring Helmet/Battles/Tomahawk drummer John Stanier, The Police's Stewart Copeland, and Wintersleep's Loel Campbell, if you're interested in a top-5)...

Campanella is a powerful drummer with a propulsive sense of groove. he's also an adept pianist, and sets up a keyboard left of his snare drum. he's taught himself how to play the drums with his right hand, while playing keys with his left, and it's ****ing awesome to watch (he describes the process in this interview, if you're interested in hearing more: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Wj75uTmEtY). anyway, immediately after the show, i bought dredg's second album, which was for sale at their merch booth. it blew me away. they're distinctly different from Deftones, but they're a band born from the same desire to craft forward-thinking alternative metal. there were not a lotta bands like them in the first half of the last decade, and dredg were definitely the first band i could recommend in a "you heard it here first" fashion. they weren't on the radio. the internet hadn't made them accessible yet. not a lotta people had heard about this quirky progressive alt metal band from the Bay Area. my friends often looked to me for musical recommendations, and dredg are a special band for me, given that they represent the first new band about which i could enthusiastically say "check this **** out"...

now, fast-forward beyond their third album, and the band is in identity crisis, trying to figure out what their next step is. after toiling away in the studio for a couple of years, they ended up with their fourth album, The Pariah, the Parrot, the Delusion. TPTPTD is a concept piece about seeking information at a time in our history when everybody wants to dupe you, wants to see you pacified and deluded. the message of the album resonates with me, from the sarcasm of "Ireland" to the religious criticism of "Information" to the compassion of "Cartoon Showroom." all told, i think it's dredg's crowning achievement, an ambitious and diverse album crafted at the height of their creative powers. but really, it's a drummer's record above all else, and that's why i've picked it here. if you love an album that grooves, this album's for you...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
For my next pick, I am going to take my favorite southern rock album of all time... really makes me feel like a country boy listening to it...

I select:

The B-52's - The B-52's -1979
58469_2.jpg

Only nine songs, but what an incredible nine songs... Planet Claire... 52 Girls... Dance This Mess Around... Rock Lobster!!! Lava... There's a Moon in the Sky (Called the Moon)... Hero Worship... 6060-842... Downtown... Incredible album!!! Ricky Wilson played his guitar all weirdly tuned and missing two strings and it ripped! Fred's talking was weird... Cindy and Kate's singing... high energy, fun album. Love this album... if you have never heard it, hear it.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Growl? Must be 'cause you're a cold, unfeeling robot-man whose very life essence would be drained if you had even one minute of unabashed fun.

but I do know someone in this draft who will love the pick.
Are you referring to the person who's seen them in concert about 16 times (including once as a toddler who probably shouldn't have been in that bar)? She probably thinks NoBonus should have embedded this song, instead.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Mr. S£im Citrus

Doryphore of KingsFans.com
Staff member
Working on my write-up for my next pick, since it's probably safe from being gotten by anyone else... Do you guys think I've been over-sharing? Because I can stop. To be honest, I've felt a little uncomfortable disclosing as much as I have, but I've been trying to seek catharsis in this draft, as well; that's at least fifty percent of the reason why I agreed to participate.
 

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
Working on my write-up for my next pick, since it's probably safe from being gotten by anyone else... Do you guys think I've been over-sharing? Because I can stop. To be honest, I've felt a little uncomfortable disclosing as much as I have, but I've been trying to seek catharsis in this draft, as well; that's at least fifty percent of the reason why I agreed to participate.
Personally, I think sharing the emotions behind your suggestions has made your list all the more compelling because it gives us an insight into how the music influenced times in your life and how times in your life influenced the music you listened to. I think this has been an incredible draft in that regard in that I've learned a lot about some of my fellow drafters (including the fact that my daughter is a pick thief who absolutely cannot be trusted).
 
Working on my write-up for my next pick, since it's probably safe from being gotten by anyone else... Do you guys think I've been over-sharing? Because I can stop. To be honest, I've felt a little uncomfortable disclosing as much as I have, but I've been trying to seek catharsis in this draft, as well; that's at least fifty percent of the reason why I agreed to participate.
I don't think you are over sharing and appreciate that you are willing to do so. Your responses are also well written. Although dont do anything you're not comfortable with.

I probably fall into the undersharing category. It is always very difficult to know how much to write.
 
Nostalgia pick to not totally miss out on the crotch grabbing. If I'm stuck on an island by myself I need some upbeat fare to energize my morning runs. This album helped all throughout high school as I ran 70+ miles weekly. With my 16th pick, I choose:

The Offspring - Smash - 1993



Excellent running tune!

Track List:

1. Time to Relax - 0:25
2. Nitro (Youth Energy) - 2:27
3. Bad Habit - 3:43
4. Gotta Get Away - 3:52
5. Genocide - 3:33
6. Something to Believe In - 3:17
7. Come Out and Play - 3:17
8. Self Esteem - 4:17
9. It'll Be a Long Time - 2:43
10. Killboy Powerhead - 2:02
11. What Happened to You? - 2:12
12. So Alone - 1:17
13. Not the One - 2:54
14. Smash - 10:42

More: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smash_(The_Offspring_album)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Working on my write-up for my next pick, since it's probably safe from being gotten by anyone else... Do you guys think I've been over-sharing? Because I can stop. To be honest, I've felt a little uncomfortable disclosing as much as I have, but I've been trying to seek catharsis in this draft, as well; that's at least fifty percent of the reason why I agreed to participate.
it's what i've enjoyed most about your picks.

:)
 

pdxKingsFan

So Ordinary That It's Truly Quite Extraordinary
Staff member
Working on my write-up for my next pick, since it's probably safe from being gotten by anyone else... Do you guys think I've been over-sharing? Because I can stop. To be honest, I've felt a little uncomfortable disclosing as much as I have, but I've been trying to seek catharsis in this draft, as well; that's at least fifty percent of the reason why I agreed to participate.
I read them. It makes it a lot easier to evaluate music I don't personally listen to. Keep it up.
 
OK - I am going to take another band that i dont think has a very large fanbase, but at least i can be sure that there won't be as much animosity towards this pick as my last one. I really can't explain what it is i like about them, the music, even if its a heavy subject, has always been updeat and makes me smile. Also great music for driving down the 5 and swerving from lane to lane with no traffic around. Random, but true.

Wheatus - Wheatus - 2000

wheatus-5144f1c42ea0a.jpg


And don't forget Wiki
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hey all. Happy Saturday. A big rugby match on tonight :)

My selection is-

Brown Sugar. D'Angelo. 1995.

image.jpg

I possess very few of the qualities D'Angelo flaunts on this album. I believe all romantic pursuits exist solely to remind me of this fact. So Brown Sugar is a nice escape. A little surprised (overjoyed) the album is available in round 16 but not at all complaining.

I did not know until checking the wiki page- but the album was produced both in NYC and at the poookie lab in Sacramento.

Wiki
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brown_Sugar_(D'Angelo_album)

Questlove also tells of the time D'Angelo stood up Annie Liebowitz here:
http://www.hypnagogics.com/questo/#!/d-angelo

The song cruisin
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Spike

Subsidiary Intermediary
Staff member
There have been some great late round picks! Odelay in 15 was a steal, but Master of Puppets in 16 was absolutely criminal. Looking forward to the last few rounds.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.