I like Shaw too--fresh face, new guy on the job, currently an assistant coach for one of the better ran systems and better teams in the league, etc. I think he can relate to players well (did that during the Kobe/Shaq years) so he'll probably command respect from his players. But the coaching--it can go either way. We'll have to see about that, but it can be a gamble worth taking. If he starts losing games in succession because he doesn't get the most out of his talent, he doesn't especially run plays well, etc. then he will be canned. I remember when Terry Porter was our assistant coach for a time, became the young coach of the Bucks, made a solid first impression, but the next season he turned in a craptacular season and got canned. Being a new coach, I think there may be a bit of a rocky road for him so I don't expect him to start winning immediately, but he's definitely a guy who if things start clicking eventually can be a coach for a long time to come.
I actually want Tommy Thibodeau here--we need a proven defensive system, and we haven't been a good defensive team for a while. Ron Artest couldn't salvage us last year, and this year we had a string of games where we gave up like 120+ points. Thibodeau also comes from a winning system (Houston, Boston), has proven to be the architect behind those teams' defensive schemes, and will probably immediately increase our defense tenfold if he comes here. With Shaw, there's nothing tangible yet--being able to relate to players does not automatically translate to on-court success.