I agree, but with a few asterisks
. These are moot now with Beal's trade to Suns, but the general points remain.
- Beal is not guaranteed to carve out those minutes. Over the last two seasons, not only has he played fewer games, but his PPG have also come down.
- He's been the top dog in W for a long time. With Suns, he'll be competing with Ayton as the third option. Would have been a similar story here.
- Star power matters more in the playoffs. We have to establish the tradition of going there consistently. We can't take it as a given (though I think the team showed maturity in the playoffs last year, giving hopes for this year).
- Depth matters a lot in the regular season. We were particularly blessed last season. Won't happen often. Sacrificing depth for a player who might himself be out of lineup for long periods is massively risky.
- It's quite possible that in two seasons, Kevin is actually the better player, period. Not, "if Beal is healthy" kind of scenario. Huerter is just better. I think it's even likely.
The points you raise about Holmes are very valid, but in fact, they are an indication that moving an overpriced player is not easy. No idea if Monte fielded offers, and if so, what was available. However, given that Holmes is not a starting quality center for most teams, why would teams trade for a backup center making that much money, as you yourself suggest. Typically, you have to attach assets to move such a player.
For people thinking Suns got Beal for free, yes in terms of talent. However, it's a huge financial commitment. The owners have decided to go all in, and buy a championship. Let's see if it works out.