dbl07 said:
I know that KT doesn't match up well with premiere PFs in the West. Duncan, KG, Nowitzki, and Brand obviously, but is there anyone else THAT much better than KT?
Well let's look at that.
Starting power forwards in the West:
Duncan
Garnett
Nowitzki
Stoudemire/Marion
Brand
Gasol
Randolph
Boozer
Odom
Martin
Murphy
Evans
Howard
Brown
You could trade KT for exactly two of the guys on that list. He of course is "better" than Evans as well, but Evans' banging/boarding game was so critical to the Sonics' success this year that they would almost surely value Reggie higher.
Much as I really really enjoyed those great old lottery days for us, I have absolutely no desire to return to them with a new mini-lottery team PF. And that's what KT is, has been for his entire career. A part time starting/low minute PF on a succession of lottery teams.
There are three things right at the core of being a "power" forward that KT cannot give you:
1) no post game, so no spacing problems for other team, no double teams, no structured ability to throw the ball in and play the inside/outside game. He can post a smaller player, but there are no smaller PFs.
2) no shotblocking, so no ability to be a significant help defender. People dirve at the rim at will against him and ignore him -- indeed half the OGs/SFs out there are bigger than he is. If somebody beats one of our perimeter players, they are going right to the hoop and we have no answer.
3) no ability to stop a good post player in the post, or great offensive PF period. If you had a great shotblocker playing next to him you might be able to make up for #2, but there is no real way to make up for #3 other than putting in somebody else or switching him off to somebody else to cover for his weakness. Tim Duncan, Kevin Garnett, Dirk Nowtizki -- these are the gatekeepers, and they're 7'0" tall, while Kenny is the same height as Doug Christie, and not particularly powerfully built either. They completely ignore him.