Had Salmons not fallen off a cliff (which nobody could have predicted) it wouldn't look like a bad trade at all.
Actually, at the time the trade happened, everybody on these boards were scratching their heads about the trade. Everybody thought that there would be another trade to follow, because it didn't make any sense to bring a black hole onto a team that already had several black holes.
That's all anybody talked about at the time. We kept thinking another trade was going to happen at any moment, and then when we found out that the move wasn't to facilitate another trade, everyone was pretty much dumbfounded.