From a Non-Kings Fan: It's Not the Coach....

Status
Not open for further replies.
#1
After listening to KHTK 1140 and reading many of the posts here I thought some of you may be interested (and may even need to read) what a Non-Kings fan makes of your team. As a Phoenix Suns fan I've seen more than my fair share of ownership and management/coaching problems with the Suns.

First let me say this I live in the foothills of Sacramento and as mentioned I am a Phoenix Suns fan but in am also just a longtime fan of the NBA in general. I have never considered myself an actual Kings fan but I do go to a game every once while and obviously because I live here watch a lot of the games on TV. During the Vlade/Webber era I could not help but root for them as I think any fan of pure basketball and unselfish play had to appreciate that team. Even now I root for the Kings to do well because even though they are not "my team", they are the local team and Sacramento is just such a great and unique market for a pro sports franchise. It's better for Sacramento and better for NBA when the Kings are good. It's a shame now that they are playing so poorly for several years in a row now and that cannot be helping the efforts to keep them here.

Now onto the actual subject of this thread. In the last couple weeks and especially after the last couple of games, the general consensus of this board is that Keith Smart needs to be fired. I even remember seeing these threads last season that he needed to be fired not too long after he took over for Westphal.

"He needs to be fired" was also the general consensus of the fans (and this board) in regards to Paul Westphal. "He needs to be fired" was also the general consensus of the fans with Kenny Natt who took over for Reggie Theus who was fired (and most of the fans thought he should be). Remember Reggie Theus is the guy that took over for Eric Musselman who the fans also hated and constantly posted about on this board that he needed to be fired.

Is anybody seeing a pattern here??? Since 2007 the Kings have had 5 different coaches and for the most part the team has played terrible, With each new coach and terrible season, the consensus among the fans (especially on this board) is that whoever the current coach is, they need to be fired.

I'm sorry but when you have 5 different coaches in less than 6 seasons and the team sucks all of those seasons, the real problem isn't the coach. That's just illogical to assume it's always the coach and I if some of you took a step back and saw that you literally blame each new coach every single season, you'd realize maybe it really isn't the coach after all. He's only a small part of the equation when it comes to organizational failure.

The problem is the players themselves, at the end of the day it always comes down to the players. The talent level on this team isn't as good as many seem to think it is and it's just a poorly constructed team.

So while the players are not getting the job done, their performance (or lack thereof) ultimately falls on the GM and especially in the case of the Kings..... the owners who have assembled this roster. Reason I mention the owners, as just as like what happened in Phoenix, often times the GM is at the mercy of what the owners want to spend or more specifically what they don't want to spend. I watched the Suns owner Robert Sarver take a perennial contender and turn them into the mediocre (at best) team they are now all because he wanted to save a few bucks and turn a profit off the team. Sarver used to sell draft picks like Rajon Rondo to other teams for cash. The Maloofs aren't really into selling draft picks but we all know they are the meddling type and make some of Petrie's decisions for him.

Is Keith Smart a good coach? No not really from what I've seen and some of his moves and lineups have me scratching my head too. This can be said for any coach though, even the best coaches like Phil Jackson have weird little quirks, annoyances, and biases that anger a portion of their fan-base. After watching the NBA for many years it's clear that no head coach is perfect. Keith Smart definitely has some quirks and annoyances but ultimately it falls on the individual performances of his players (especially his best players). Curiously Keith Smart seemed to be perceived as a much better coach when he was with the Warriors.

Now about those players....

Tyreke Evans is highly overrated by the average Kings fan and when you have a team where Tyreke Evans is the first or second best player......by default you are a bad team. He's just another volume scoring combo guard that puts up big numbers on terrible teams.

Unfortunately I think many fans and even some experts feel that Tyreke Evans is some sort of foundation type player or budding star but the reality is players with his skill-set are a dime-a-dozen and they don't help you win because they don't make anybody on their team better. I remember when Ben Gordon was supposedly a rising star and was being held down as the "sixth man" on the Bulls. Long story short, Ben Gordon went to Detroit to get more numbers and more money and Detroit has sucked ever since.

Tyreke is great at getting to the basket (for himself) but as we all know now, he can't shoot and more importantly he does nothing to make his teammates better. Tyreke for the most part only passes to teammates as a last resort because he can't get his own shot off. If anybody knows anything from watching the Vlade/Webber era of the Kings it's that good teams tend to want to pass the ball to each other and actually enjoy getting easy baskets for the teammates. Bad teams have a "me first" mentality and that tone is usually set by some sort of scoring combo guard like Tyreke. When your best player feels burdened having the pass the ball to another player that's a recipe for failure. The only time it even remotely works is when that best player just has a ridiculously high skill and shooting level like Kobe or Durant......and even Kobe had to learn that without making his teammates better he could not win a title.

Bottom line is that as long as Tyreke is the first or second best player on the Kings they are going to be a bad team. End of story, guys like Tyreke exist to put up good numbers on bad teams. Same can be said for Al Jefferson on Utah that we saw last night.

DeMarcus Cousins is a very talented but as we know he's also a headcase and very immature. Watching some of the games this year he actually seems to have regressed and it appears the selfish "me first" forced shooting mentality is starting to get to him too. When you play with guys like Tyreke, Salmons, and Marcus though I guess that kind of mentality starts to rub off. I thought DeMarcus was going to be the kind of guy that you could run an offense through and make other guys (his guards) better but sadly he seems to now just rush and force most of his touches on the offensive end. Case in point his .427 FG% which is pathetic for a PF. The question is can he be fixed and even if you can get his game back on track can you ever get his head straight too?

I actually think some of the Kings role-players are talented and could really thrive in the right situations but when your best two players are Tyreke Evans and a suddenly regressing DeMarcus Cousins it really doesn't matter about any of the role-players. The tone is set with those two guys.

Everybody wanted to blame Keith Smart last night but is it's Keith Smart's fault that DeMarcus forced two or three possessions in a row? Is it Keith Smart's fault that Tyreke Evans took two terrible shots in the closing minutes and did not even attempt to find teammates on those possessions.

Is it Keith Smart's fault that Tyreke Evans completely blew his assignment and let Gordon Hayward get a wide open jumper to win the game? Jason Thompson saw the play developing and was screaming at Tyreke to get out on Hayward before the screen was set, and yet Tyreke fell asleep and did not see the obvious play coming. If Keith Smart is such a terrible coach, how come Jason Thompson knew what was going on and how to stop it (and not even the guy he was guarding) but Tyreke didn't? Sorry but that comes down to the individual player. Great players and team leaders don't have massive blunders like this and so badly blow a defensive assignment to end a game.

After I write all of this above (and yes I know it's way too much), the problem with the Kings isn't the coach , it's the players. The same players that some of you don't seem to realize just are not good enough to be the primary pieces on a good team. They can fire Keith Smart and move on to a 6th coach in 6 years but short of 3 or 4 more wins what does that accomplish? The team will still suck and the same players that are causing all of the losing (and same management that chose those players) will still be in place.

Moral of the story is that if this team is ever going to get back on the right track, Tyreke Evans has to go and it would not hurt if Petrie either went with him or the Maloofs allowed him to actually do his job again.
 

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
#2
Interesting post. While I may not agree with all your assessments I do think you bring up valid points for discussion. I hope you have a flak jacket, however. I suspect you will be blasted by some around here. Be sure and duck...
 

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
#3
Is anybody seeing a pattern here??? Since 2007 the Kings have had 5 different coaches and for the most part the team has played terrible, With each new coach and terrible season, the consensus among the fans (especially on this board) is that whoever the current coach is, they need to be fired.

I'm sorry but when you have 5 different coaches in less than 6 seasons and the team sucks all of those seasons, the real problem isn't the coach. That's just illogical to assume it's always the coach and I if some of you took a step back and saw that you literally blame each new coach every single season, you'd realize maybe it really isn't the coach after all. He's only a small part of the equation when it comes to organizational failure.
Let me ask you a quick question sport: how many of those 5 coaches have ever coached a single game in the NBA after leaving the Kings? (let me give you a hint). How many do you think ever will?

There is a reason for that.


Now, as the real point of your 10,000 word essay seemed to be to bag on Reke, I won't imagine the answer to my little query above will have any significance to you.

P.S. BTW Keith Smart was perceived as such a good coach by the Warriors that they ****canned him after a single season for a completely inexperienced television analayst .
 
#4
If this was a year or two ago I may have agreed with your assessment on Tyreke, but based on his performance this year I have to say that you're completely wrong. Tyreke is leading us in assists this year and is a willing passer. The assist numbers aren't great, but that goes shows you just how much the rest of the team is passing.
 
#5
Welcome to the board Suns fan! Thanks for your thoughts...aa far as coaches, I think Theus got the most unfair shake out of the bunch, he was strict yet respected by his players. The bad start to that season shouldn't have resulted in his firing. With that said, Musselman, Natt, and Westphal weren't right for this job and should have never been hired. I have my own list of folks I thought would have been better for this team, regardless of who was on the team. The real beginning this downfall was letting Adelman go, followed by Bonzi Wells getting bad advice from his agent, followed by 6 years of useless plugging of holes with square pegs...followed by Maloof sabotage. It adds up to one big mess..
and even though Smart might not be the whole of the problem, he IS a big part of it.
 

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
#6
I will say this again. Keith Smart was released before the season, Rick Adelman started the season as the coach of thsi same team with this same talent we would be MUCH better. MUCH. 10gms. 15 maybe.

Trying to deny that and lay this on Reke's doorstep is asinine. There is a reckoning coming.
 
#7
It starts with the head of the organization plain and simple. As long as the Maloofs are owners, this team is going to stay mediocre with below average personnel and leadership. Smart is just a branch of the terrible ownership we have. Getting rid of him won't solve everything. It will help, but this organization will continue to be an embarrassment to the league and city as long as they are the owners. Plain and simple.
 
#8
Let me ask you a quick question sport: how many of those 5 coaches have ever coached a single game in the NBA after leaving the Kings? (let me give you a hint). How many do you think ever will?

There is a reason for that.
.
He said Smart isn't a good coach. I think his point is that there is someone, or multiple people, that hires these coaches. These are the same people that are responsible for building the team. Both the team and the coach suck. If you replace the coach, the team still sucks. Last night was an example; Tyreke lost his man on the Jazz inbound play to put them up by two. I also saw Thompson try to communicate that this guy needed to be picked up. He was left open. Sure, the coach might be responsible for the Kings being tied at the juncture of the game, but the players are too. Right now, they are both not very good.

I agree with the original poster based on what I've seen this year. Thanks for posting a dissenting opinion.
 
#9
Is anybody seeing a pattern here??? Since 2007 the Kings have had 5 different coaches and for the most part the team has played terrible, With each new coach and terrible season, the consensus among the fans (especially on this board) is that whoever the current coach is, they need to be fired.

but i think this statistic can also be used to say that the problem IS coaching, and the cheap *** maloofs just keep hiring random worthless coaches.
 

Tetsujin

The Game Thread Dude
#10
but i think this statistic can also be used to say that the problem IS coaching, and the cheap *** maloofs just keep hiring random worthless coaches.
What are you talking about? The Maloofs are the best owners in the NBA who selflessly turned down an arena deal for Sacramento's sake.
 
#12
ya the summary of the OP is that the Guy who has been hands down the best player on the team the last few games, needs to go because he is the reason they lose, while hes sitting on the bench for the whole 4th quarter
 

rainmaker

Hall of Famer
#13
No kidding you're a non-Kings fan.

A huge problem is the coaching, although it's far from the only problem. But tell me, which one of these coaches in getting head coaching jobs in the league after his stint with the Kings. Hell, none are working in the NBA in any capacity whatsoever, unless you count the D-League.

Muscleman
Theus
Natt
Westphal
now, we're dealing with Smart.

See a problem here? The problem is bleeping obvious. We keep hiring coaches who aren't NBA head coaching material.

Of course the roster doesn't fit well, and we have scumbag owners, but the talent we do have can do a hell of a lot better than it currently is, and a huge part of that is our idiot coach not having a clue what he's doing on the sideline.

As for your take on Reke, not even our own coach recognizes when he's the best player on the floor as he was yesterday, so I'm not really all that surprised you lay the blame at his feet.
 

rainmaker

Hall of Famer
#16
i feel like there are so many games we would have won if Smart put the right players back in on time. at least 4
Outside of Chicago which we lost, he hasn't actually given our starters a chance to win a game. Either the bench wins it, or the starters are put in a near impossible situation to fix the lead the bench gave up and counteract the momentum swing, and are supposed to do that and win the game in the final three minutes, usually ice cold.
 
#18
Some of you guys are just proving my point by saying things such as "best player on the team" and "he's leading the team in assists".......as if 3.5 assists per game was something to brag about. :rolleyes:

When your team is 3-9 and in last place is "best player on the team" even worth anything?

It's common knowledge that since basketball is only a 5-5 sport and theoretically one player can touch the ball just about every possession..... the primary/best players have the most impact on their teams of any of the major sports. It's the reason why any team Lebron is on right now will be default be at least pretty good if not great. More so than any other sport, the primary or "best" players have the greatest impact positively or negatively on their teams.

Tyreke Evans and DeMarcus Cousins are the best two players on the Kings and the primary focal points on the offensive end. Their team is 3-9 which is a direct reflection of their abilities to make their teammates better and ultimately win games.

The question is are these two guys winning players? Are they leaders? Do they help make their teammates better? It's painfully obvious that with Tyreke Evans the answer is NO to all three of the above questions. It's also now appearing that the same answer of NO may also be true for DeMarcus Cousins. Whatever natural ability he has to make teammates better is being overshadowed by a lack of maturity and leadership.

The reason my opening post turned into essentially a Tyreke bashing thread is simple......the Kings keep firing coaches while Tyreke remains their best player and the end result is always the same, a losing season.

Tyreke Evans also has one of the worst on court/off court worst +/- ratios in the league at -11.9. He also had one of the worst ratios in the league last season as well. The numbers show that the team plays better when he is off the floor.

That's a fact that you cannot dispute BrickLayer. The coaches keep changing, Tyreke continues as the best player, and the team keeps losing. I already stated that I don't think Keith Smart is not a good coach but is firing Keith Smart suddenly going to turn Tyreke and DeMarcus into "natural born leaders" that make their teammates better and carry them to the playoffs? Of course it's not. Even with the best coaching this team is not a playoff team with the current roster. The roster lacks shooters (especially at SF) and all 3 of it's top scorers (Tyreke, Cousins, and Thornton) seem disinterested in actually making their teammates better. That is a recipe for failure.

All I'm saying is that Keith Smart may very well get fired but it won't change the results more than a few games. The problem is the players and the people who put the roster together.

PS: For those that don't think I know what I am talking about in regards to Tyreke. I watched Steve Nash overachieve and make guys like Raja Bell, Boris Diaw, and Leandro Barbosa relevant on the Phoenix Suns. Tyreke would physically dominate Steve Nash in a game of 1-on-1 but basketball isn't about 1-on-1 and who can score more points for the back of their own trading card. Winning basketball is about having leaders that make teammates better and making your team better just by the presence of you being on the floor. When Tyreke Evans is rocking a -11.9 +/- Ratio he's not making anybody better just by being on the floor.
 
Last edited:
#19
If King trade Tyreke and Cousins to LAC for Chris Paul or Rondo + change you think King Will have better record?

for example
CP3 or Rondo/MT/Salmon or JJ/JT/Hayes

Just a reminder, whoever you traded will still be playing 30min a night - play 8min then iced 8min and so on.
 
#20
By the way I never fully stated what should be the solution for fixing this mess of a team and all of the turmoil that surrounds it.

The obvious solution that unfortunately is not reality would be for the Maloofs to sell the team and take Tyreke with them. I think it's pretty clear that the underlying cause for all of the Kings problems over the last 5+ years starts and ends with the Maloofs. When the owners started to suck at being owners......well the team started sucking too.

Short of getting rid of the Maloofs though the only real option to fix this team is to just blow the entire roster and coaching staff up. That means get rid of Coach Smart at the end of the season. Trade Tyreke and DeMarcus Cousins for a stockpile of draft picks and hope to hell that you hit paydirt on one of them and draft a natural born leader that has real "star" potential and that will make his teammates better.

The reality is that the only way this team gets better is by essentially starting over because the path that they are on now is just the road to nowhere.

If you are a Kings fan you have to ask yourself, regardless of who is the coach is Tyreke Evans ever going to lead you to win anything? Is DeMarcus Cousins ever going to lead you to win anything? If these two guys are your best players (and they will force themselves to be because they both need the ball and are incapable of being role players ) could this team ever win 50 games?
 
Last edited:
#21
Granted this team has its weaknesses. A coaching change to the best coach in the league isnt going to make this team do a 180. The roster isnt perfect. However, the MAIN weakness of this current Kings team is the inexperience and inability of the head coach. He's horrible. Anyone that can sit back and watch the Kings games objectively is able to see that the coaching of this team is flat out horrible. There are horrible lineups on the floor for extended periods of time. Players will catch fire and suddenly be benched for no reason other than "its time for the other guy to get his fair share of playing time.". No other team in the league favors a set rotation pattern over playing the best players on the team and taking advantage of mismatches. Anyone with an unbiased perspective with knowledge of the roster will also be able to agree that the level of talent on the team is better than the record suggests. This is why there are so many frustrated kings fans and players. We all expect ( with the exception of a few negative nancys )more from this group than 3-9.
 

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
#22
By the way I never fully stated what should be the solution for fixing this mess of a team and all of the turmoil that surrounds it.

The obvious solution that unfortunately is not reality would be for the Maloofs to sell the team and take Tyreke with them. I think it's pretty clear that the underlying cause for all of the Kings problems over the last 5+ years starts and ends with the Maloofs. When the owners started to suck at being owners......well the team started sucking too.

Short of getting rid of the Maloofs though the only real option to fix this team is to just blow the entire roster and coaching staff up. That means get rid of Coach Smart at the end of the season. Trade Tyreke and DeMarcus Cousins for a stockpile of draft picks and hope to hell that you hit paydirt on one of them and draft a natural born leader that has real "star" potential and that will make his teammates better.

The reality is that the only way this team gets better is by essentially starting over because the path that they are on now is just the road to nowhere.

If you are a Kings fan you have to ask yourself, regardless of who is the coach is Tyreke Evans ever going to lead you to win anything? Is DeMarcus Cousins ever going to lead you to win anything? If these two guys are your best players (and they will force themselves to be because they both need the ball and are incapable of being role players ) could this team ever win 50 games?
Ok, this has gotten ridiculous.

Initial note: ONE coach, and one coach only has been fired while Reke was here. And he was fired not because of Reke but because of a serious, and seriously stupid, conflict wiht DeMarcus.

Now, I want to explain something to you. I gave you the first post. You have posted here once or twice a year for several years. But you made a mistake coming on and announcing yourself as a Suns fan. You announce yourself a Suns fan, start a thread trashing the team, and you expect what exactly? Well, we're going to start by locking this thread. I will allow all kinds of stupidity from fans of the team. But nobody comes in here from outside, onto our board, and trashes our team. That's called trolling.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.