Denver trades Middlebrooks to San Francisco

#1
By Jon Wilner, Mercury News
July 16, 2005

The 49ers acquired reserve cornerback Willie Middlebrooks from Denver on Friday for defensive end John Engelberger, who did not fit into their new 3-4 defense.

The deal might have been completed earlier in the week if the 49ers hadn't had to perform an extended background check on Middlebrooks. The former first-round draft pick is facing misdemeanor domestic violence charges for allegedly trying to hit and choke his girlfriend on New Year's Day in Aurora, Colo., according to published reports. The trial is scheduled for Oct. 11. Middlebrooks has pleaded not guilty.




Coach Mike Nolan said the 49ers checked into the incident and don't anticipate problems. ``Our counsel looked at the reports, and everything is good,'' he said.

Nolan added that Middlebrooks ``certainly made a bad choice, but he had no record prior and nothing since.''

Both players must pass physicals for the trade to become official. Engelberger missed mini-camps because of a bad wrist. Middlebrooks hurt his lower leg in December and finished the season on injured reserve. But his agent, Drew Rosenhaus, said Middlebrooks is healthy and eager for a fresh start.

``The 49ers did their research and found out that Willie is a high-character guy who was in a bad situation,'' Rosenhaus said. ``Sometimes guys just need a change of scenery.''

The Broncos were well-stocked at cornerback but shopping for defensive ends. They called the 49ers, who had an expendable end but needed help in the secondary.

``We didn't want to match their request for a draft pick, so we started talking about players,'' Nolan said. ``Engelberger was the first one they brought up and the only one we talked about.''

Engelberger, 28, had six sacks last season as an outside pass rusher in the 49ers' 4-3 alignment. But at 268 pounds, he is considered too small for the 3-4, where defensive ends often play in the interior. The 49ers signed free agent Marques Douglas, who played with Baltimore, in April with the expectation that he would start in place of Engelberger.

Middlebrooks was an All-Big Ten cornerback at Minnesota who left college after his junior year. He was the 24th pick of the 2001 draft, then spent four years in Denver as an injury-plagued reserve.

The 49ers expect him to compete for a starting spot with Shawntae Spencer and Ahmed Plummer, who has not played since October because of a bulging disk in his neck. (Former starter Mike Rumph is moving to safety.)

``It's my hope that he would at least be a third . . . corner for us,'' Nolan said of Middlebrooks. ``We're hoping he competes for the second, even the first spot. We haven't had a lot of durability at the position.''

Middlebrooks, 26, has two years left on his contract, Rosenhaus said, but the second year is voidable if he meets certain playing-time requirements this season. Rosenhaus declined to disclose Middlebrooks' salary.

• Nolan on the Alex Smith contract negotiations: ``I expect it will go down to the last couple days before training camp. It might go into training camp. That wouldn't surprise me. But one way or another, I feel Alex will be prepared when he comes in.''


http://sports.yahoo.com/nba/news?slug=knight-_WWW_2002382648_soni15&prov=knight&type=lgns


Is anyone else dissappointed by this? Now, I don't know anything about Middlebrooks, but for all the talk about improving and cleaning up this organization, they go out and grab a guy like this. I would imagine choking your girlfriend is certainly a "bad choice". Way to go Niners, clear out this organization of whatever class is left in it.
 
T

thesanityannex

Guest
#3
captain bill said:
By Jon Wilner, Mercury News
July 16, 2005


``The 49ers did their research and found out that Willie is a high-character guy who was in a bad situation,'' Rosenhaus said. .
The definition of high-character guy must have changed this year.
 

SLAB

Hall of Famer
#6
Well, with the 3-4 you need your D-linemen to be big, and Engleberger is undersized.

So there wasn't much use in keeping him if he wasn't going to play or play much less effectivly than his previous season.
 

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
#7
...misdemeanor domestic violence charges for allegedly trying to hit and choke his girlfriend on New Year's Day in Aurora, Colo...
We might want to actually let him have his day in court before we find him guilty.

Mike Nolan is a class act. If the organization did an in-depth examination of MIddlebrooks and still decided to get him, I'm willing to wait and see what happens.
 
O

ONEZERO

Guest
#8
please god, please let football start already. i think this has been the longest offseason ever for me. and with baseball wierder than ever and basketball driving me crazy, i cant wait for my 49ers to suit up.
 

funkykingston

Super Moderator
Staff member
#9
The darkest day for me as a niners fan was when the team signed Lawrence Phillips after he had a decent season in the NFL Europe league.

It was painful for me have to root for a team that started that miserable human being at running back. Dragging a woman by her hair down flights of stairs, sexually assualting a woman at a party, punching another woman in the face for not wanting to dance with him at a club - all acts committed by Phillips. I'm not going to bother to look up his other "bad decisions", but I know at least one DUI is on the list.

Of course, Phillips couldn't even control himself within the confines of football either, having run-ins with the Rams coaching staff and then again with the 49ers. It wouldn't have made me feel any better if Phillips had been an All-Pro running back, but it makes it all the worse that my lasting memory of his failed return to the NFL was missing the blitz pickup that led to Steve Young's last concussion and eventually meant his retirement from the NFL.

In my experience, violence against women is almost never limited to a single incidence. Obviously, I'll wait to hear the facts in Middlebrook's case, but at this point in my life, I'd rather have a team that I can feel good rooting for than a championship squad full of bad guys. Nolan passed on David Boston and Koren Robinson becuase of their off-the-field behavior, despite wide receiver being the team's biggest position of need, so I assume that he really thinks Middlebrooks is a decent guy. We'll see.
 

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
#10
I found this about the incident:

Broncos defensive back held on assault charge
By The Associated Press

AURORA, Colo. — Denver Broncos defensive back Willie Middlebrooks appeared in court Monday on charges of third-degree assault and harassment stemming from an alleged fight with a female friend early New Year's Day.

Middlebrooks, 25, was arrested Saturday on the misdemeanor charges and held in Arapahoe County jail. Middlebrooks had not posted the $20,000 bond as of noon Monday, court spokeswoman Lori Rutlege said.

A pretrial conference was set for Feb. 2.

Sheriff's officials were called to a home around 3:30 a.m. Saturday on a report of domestic violence, Sheriff Grayson Robinson said. A woman said she had gone out with Middlebrooks and a friend on New Year's Eve and went home after she and Middlebrooks had a fight.

She told deputies she fell asleep and woke up when Middlebrooks allegedly came home and assaulted her. She was treated for minor injuries at a hospital, sheriff's officials said.

Middlebrooks, who was not at the house when deputies arrived, was arrested at his home that afternoon.

Middlebrooks has no previous record in Arapahoe County, Robinson said.

Middlebrooks has not played with the Broncos since suffering a season-ending leg injury against Miami on Dec. 12.

Originally published Jan. 4, 2005

http://www.coloradoan.com/news/coloradoanpublishing/Football2004/Broncos/season/010405_middlebrooks.html