Defensive Play - Can you yell in the face of your opponent?

#1
This happens all the time in the playground, and it can throw off your shot. Can you do it in the NBA? I believe you can not do this at the free-throw line but have never heard it addressed for active play.

Before you jump all over me for this question, consider the following: In golf, players detest a yell right as they putt. Silence is mandatory. In tennis, the umpire tells the crowd to be quite, particularly during the service. In fact, in the Australian Open fourth-seeded Del Porto complained on more than one occasion that a man shouting from the stands through off his game. In other matches, players have complained/missed shots because of a whistle from the audience at the moment of serve.

Now the NBA is a little different in that the crowd is generally noisy. As a result, even though noisy, the noise is CONSTANT. Such constant background noise will not bother a player. It is the sudden change from silence to a loud noise that will throw off an athlete. For example, if you are jogging past a backyard that has a dog with a loud bark, it will startle you EVEN if you are expecting it. This is why fans raising their voices to distract a free-throw shooter does no good. The noise is constant. However, if the fans would be silent and then explode into noise just a the shooter goes into his shooting motion, it may have an effect. In that same vein, I think if a fan blew an air horn right behind the basket just as a player was about to shoot a free throw the players would complain.

So if you are guarding a player and yell LOUD into his face just prior to the release of his shot, I contend it may throw off his shot. You see it all the time in the playground, so many think it is effective. But is it legal? Comments?
 
Last edited:
#4
Mike Bibby used to clap all the time when a shooter would shoot over him....never saw him get a technical for it though
Yeah and that made him great on D :rolleyes:

best thing to just do on defense is put the palm of your face in their eye sight...

unorthodox methods of defense eh?

try not taking a shower before the game.... then raise your pits on their shot

theres no such thing as a technical foul for bad hygiene :D

other than that just work your heart out in D
 
Last edited:

Warhawk

Give blood and save a life!
Staff member
#6
unorthodox methods of defense eh?

try not taking a shower before the game.... then raise your pits on their shot

theres no such thing as a technical foul for bad hygiene :D
I forget who it was that used to eat some nasty-smelling cheese (limburger, IIRC) before each game so they had rotten breath when they got in the face of their opponent for just that reason.
 
#9
its all about smack talk on the black top. I would personally choose to yell in their face after making a three or something. or go with desean stevenson "you can't see" handle signal. tends to get in their head, of course alot of NBA players are mentally tougher as they should be :rolleyes:
 
#11
Garnett likes to intimidate his opponents by calling them the "N-Word", as in shouting at the top of his lungs, "Give me the f----ing ball! That "N----r" can not f----ing guard me!"

Source: Tim Donaghy, "Personal Foul"
if basketball was like the road and the refs were like cops

the nickname The Big Ticket suits him just well.....

i mean seriously theres a thin line between being passionate about the game and making it personal

i guess his bball iq goes down the drain everytime he bangs his head on that post
 
#12
Marc Gasol wrote an entry in his blog about trash talking, Duncan and Garnett in the NBA a few days ago.

http://www.marca.com/blogs/marc-gasol/2010/01/18/kevin-garnett-tim-duncan-y-el-trash.html

Basicly he says there are too much trash talking in NBA compared to Europe. He says not everybody uses it to intimdate, but to motivate theirselves. He agree Garnett is the one who talks the most on the court, and he says he doesn't mind about the trash talking, everyone has his techniques. He doesn't like to talk in the court however.

Before that, he says he thinks Duncan is the best active player in the NBA and the best face of the league, because he plays very hard but as a gentleman. And he agrees with him being chosen player of the decade by several media.

It's poorly translated here:

http://babelfish.yahoo.com/translate_url?doit=done&tt=url&intl=1&fr=bf-home&trurl=http://www.marca.com/blogs/marc-gasol/2010/01/18/kevin-garnett-tim-duncan-y-el-trash.html&lp=es_en&btnTrUrl=Translate


There are basketball related words that are very bad translated due to being polysemic words out of context:equipment = team, party = game/match
 
Last edited:
#13
Marc Gasol wrote an entry in his blog about trash talking, Duncan and Garnett in the NBA a few days ago.

http://www.marca.com/blogs/marc-gasol/2010/01/18/kevin-garnett-tim-duncan-y-el-trash.html

Basicly he says there are too much trash talking in NBA compared to Europe. He says not everybody uses it to intimdate, but to motivate theirselves. He agree Garnett is the one who talks the most on the court, and he says he doesn't mind about the trash talking, everyone has his techniques. He doesn't like to talk in the court however.

Before that, he says he thinks Duncan is the best active player in the NBA and the best face of the league, because he plays very hard but as a gentleman. And he agrees with him being chosen player of the decade by several media.

It's poorly translated here:

http://babelfish.yahoo.com/translate_url?doit=done&tt=url&intl=1&fr=bf-home&trurl=http://www.marca.com/blogs/marc-gasol/2010/01/18/kevin-garnett-tim-duncan-y-el-trash.html&lp=es_en&btnTrUrl=Translate


There are basketball related words that are very bad translated due to being polysemic words out of context:equipment = team, party = game/match
I kind of have a hard time picturing duncan being a potty mouth.. and right to name him player of the decade such a nice man :D
 
#14
I don't really see a problem with it - there are boundaries, but what KG does is fine to me. Classless maybe, but nothing worth writing home about. Everybody motivates themselved differently. As long as there is no physical contact, let it be. You know, sticks and stones - these are grown men, many whom have come from pretty crappy parts of the country; pretty sure they've heard FAR worse and done far worse. On D, your job is to stop the guy... mental intimidation is part of the game. I'm not advocating it, and I wish they didn't do it, but not as big of a problem as people have noted.