I believe he was one of the group with the philosophy of take who you believe is the best player available, regardless of fit or position. Now Mitchell is starting pg for Miami, so he was an asset that never got the chance to really show his value. He would have ended up starting pg for the Kings, had they kept him for the length of his rookie contract.
The bigger mistake was signing Vesenkov and not really being committed to playing him, which then led to giving up Mitchell and him to be able to sign DeRozan
The Sasha Vezenkov situation was definitely a big miss. Coming off that 7 game playoff series against Golden State, his was the only big contract handed out that summer and Mike Brown never put him fully into the rotation. That was probably where the McNair/Brown partnership started to fall apart.
And there seems to be quite a bit of selective memory going on with Monte's first round draft picks.
2020: Even in retrospect, Tyrese Haliburton was clearly the best player on the board in 2020 at the 12th pick and the only other players who are even close (Maxey, Quickley, Bane) are also guards.
2021: This was a pretty wide open field at #9 and while Moody, Johnson, Sengun, Murphy, and even Herb Jones had supporters here, none of them was an obvious pick over Davion Mitchell. We did not need another PG at that time but I thought that Mitchell was the most impactful defensive player that I saw in that draft and his defense has been as advertised. For the past two seasons he's been a 40% three point shooter, a steady lead guard who doesn't turn the ball over (he's got a 5:1 assist to turnover ration this season) and remains one of the best guards in the league at stopping dribble penetration. The only problem here is that he was a poor fit for that roster and McNair went all-in on building around Fox who ultimately was not all-in on him.
2022: There are only 4 guys who could maybe have a case for being better picks at #4 than Keegan Murray so far (based on Win Shares or WS/48) and that's Jalen Williams, Jalen Duren, Mark Williams, and Walker Kessler. I don't remember any of them being heavily in play for our pick. Not quite as clear cut as the Haliburton pick since we've had less time for these players to mature, but I'm happy we got Keegan here.
2023: With the Kings finishing 3rd in the West this season, the pick was #24 and while trading out of the first round was disappointing at the time, so far it looks like Monte made the right call there.
2024: This is tough. There are other guys I wanted here more than Devin Carter (Yves Missi, DaRon Holmes, or Ryan Dunn would have been better
fits and I liked the upside gamble on Collier) but we know that McNair had a Best Player Available strategy and if Carter wasn't the consensus pick there he was very close to it. It's just a shame he's barely gotten an opportunity to play with the shoulder injury and subsequent roster machinations crowding him out.
That was all 5 of the drafts McNair was in charge for and there are no big misses in any of them. You can only control what you can control so Kuminga, Giddey, and Wagner going #6, #7, and #8 ahead of Davion in 2021 is not McNair's fault. I appreciate that he quite often targeted defensive role-players with his second round picks and UDFA's which led to uncovering serviceable NBA rotation players like Keon Ellis and Neemias Queta. And to call those Mitchell and Carter picks
misses in retrospect is to argue for fit over best player available which is a whole other discussion that we've already had and will continue to have -- I think it's a tough position to argue for when talking about late lottery picks given how many of the players taken in the late lottery and later end up being out of the league or close to it by the end of their first contract.