Setting aside Nance for a second since I don’t have him playing as big of a role as DFS…it’s already hard enough to find a team willing to trade us a long, athletic PF who can defend and space the floor. It’s even more difficult to find a team willing to trade us a long, athletic PF who can defend and space the floor
while being on an upward trajectory. Those types of players are rarely available for trade. I think we need to be realistic about how that type of player can be acquired especially since it’s more crucial for our team to add that type of player to this roster (since we have Sabonis at C).
I’m not saying that we shouldn’t develop Colby and Isaac, but I think it would be a mistake as a team hoping to make the playoffs to rely on them as our 8th, 9th, or 10th man when our roster is fully healthy because that likely means our 11th-15th men are even worse.
I’d much rather have stronger bench players in our rotation to give us a better shot at making the playoffs and allow those young guys an opportunity to prove themselves when injuries inevitably come (Monk, Carter, Huerter, DeRozan, Murray, Lyles, and Sabonis have all missed time this year with injuries. Not to mention Carter has been out all year thus far). And they’ve looked decent here and there, but I wouldn’t say either of them have looked as good/impactful as Ellis did last year.
I say continue to have Colby and Isaac backfill when we have injuries and allow them another offseason to develop their game. Then during 2025 training camp, they have a shot at forcing Brown’s hand to be a rotation player. If they’re not at that level yet, have them fill the same role as the previous year which continues to give them some decent NBA minutes to grow their game while at the same time we’re not sacrificing our “win now” goal.
I think saying that a player is “producing at an All-Star level” when he’s putting up 22/4/4 with a 57% TS% is a little disingenuous. The last time he was an All-Star was when he put up 25/5/5 with a 59% TS% and that was in a weak eastern conference. Now don’t get me wrong. Those stats are solid for an offensive scorer but I don’t consider him an All-Star level player as you alluded to.
As for the trade that brought DeRozan here, I want to be clear…
- I think the trade improved our team/roster today
- I don’t think we overpaid value-wise to land DeRozan
I can hold both of those opinions while still holding the position that I think adding DeRozan limits our ceiling as a team.
As for Murray, I think you’re more optimistic on his offensive potential than I am at this point. Year 3 is usually when you see that jump and we’re not even talking about someone that came into the league at 18/19. Murray is 24 today and will be 25 at the start of next season. How many players at the age are making significant strides in their game offensively? And I do think he needs to make significant strides offensively. His handle has not been good and it severely limits his ability to create his own offense.
I see Murray (at best) as a 4th option on a contending team but more likely he settles in as a 5th option on a contending team (which is what he is on our team today).
I’m not going to force you to succumb to my trade proposal
but I guess I would ask you…what would you do if you were Monte?