The dude has played for 21 seasons. Why so many act so shocked when somebody that plays that long starts setting or breaking records escapes me.
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar also played similarly as long (20 seasons) and left the NBA as the all-time leading scorer and leader in many other categories too. But he wouldn’t have had Wilt Chamberlain played 20 seasons instead of 14.
And LBJ wouldn’t be the all-time leader, either, if numerous other players had decided to hang around and play as long, namely Michael Jeffrey Jordan -- who retired for the bulk of 2 seasons during the prime of his career then retired again for a few years before attempting a comeback. Had MJ never retired and just played continuously through the early 2000’s — he’d probably have one more title (1998-1999) and would almost assuredly be the leagues all-time leader.
Now, before anybody tries to pull the “those guys weren’t able to play to the same level for as long as LBJ“ card, I’ll counter with the ruleset being much different (and more physical) before 2003, 2004ish. That’s when “hand-checking” was eliminated and other rules began emerging to foster more scoring. Not only that, LBJ never had to deal with “Jordan Rules” getting pummeled and knocked to the floor most every time he stepped floor in the paint. If he had, he’d be far more worn down and injured at this stage of his career.
The likes of Bird, Magic, MJ, Wilt, etc, would have been capable of playing longer and at a very high level if they played under the current rule set and state of today’s game. Same goes for the old guard of NFL players, such as Joe Montana and Dan Marino.
Regardless of and despite the difference in eras, MJ and Wilt would have set the scoring marks much higher had they played longer. Wilt surely could have played longer had he wanted to, as the dude was still showing up to open gyms and killing NBA players up to his late 40’s, early 50’s. Just ask Magic Johnson.
Circling back to the point, I sure hope James is doing things nobody else has done considering how long he’s played. That’s a testament to his talent and longevity. Great for him. But it in no way marks him as the greatest player of all time, despite what the younger generation naively believes.
He’s not even in my top 10. Not including players I never saw play live, such as Wilt, Walton, West, and Russell, I’d take MJ, Magic, Bird, Kareem, Kobe, Shaq, Duncan, Wade, Steph, and Olajuwon over him without hesitation.
KD, KG, Dirk, Barkley, Dr. J, Stockton, and Malone are close, but they didn’t win quite enough to overtake LBJ imo. But several of them were definitely much more clutch and unflappable when the going got toughest.
I’ve long been critical of the traveling Jokic, but if that dude leads Denver to another couple titles — I’ll be persuaded to take him over LBJ too. Same goes for Giannis. They both got some work to do. But they could get there rather easily, I believe.