To be fair, Hinkie did some of that botching himself what with the draft record and all.
Drafting is never a perfect science (as we well know with Vlade) but Hinkie better than anyone else in NBA history gave himself as many shots on goal to hit on a star like Simmons and Embiid. And he didn't readjust his plan before he landed on that franchise talent. He also MINED the 2nd round constantly and made it a priority.
-Drafted MCW at 11
-Drafted Embiid 3rd overall
-Turned Jrue Holiday into 2 1st round picks instead of keeping him to keep the team semi-decent.
-Payton then traded for Saric and another 1st round pick (Became Shamet)
- Traded Thad Young for a 2016 1st round pick
-Drafted Jerami Grant 39th overall
-Robert Covington-Undrafted
-Turned MCW into a 1st round pick
-Drafted Ja Okafor at 3
-
Drafted Richaun Holmes at 37
-The infamous Kings trade, got 2 picks swaps and a 1st round pick swap for cap sapce
- Put the Sixers team in place to take the easy #1 overall pick in Ben Simmons before getting fired.
So... yeah. In 3 years he found 3 absolute gems in the 2nd round, drafted Embiid, put the Sixers in place to take Simmons. So is he really all that bad at drafting? Turned MCW into a future 1st instead of paying him big money and Saric for a late lottery pick has been a good NBA player. He missed on Noel and he missed on Okafor, but this record looks very much like any good GM's in terms of hit rate. And just add his absolute mastery in asset accumulation, he's the reason the Sixers are in the position they are today. What's important here is how many opportunities the Sixers had to find franchise talent and give them the best opportunity to hit.
That's been a prevailing problem in Sacramento is we think we're further along in the rebuild than we actually are and try to speed up the timeline. There has been so many deals over the years that Sacramento passed on where they could use their cap space as asset leverage and decided to sign some middling veteran FA instead.