Should we trade for Irving?
Maybe. We should at least consider it because he's an all star and in his early-mid-20s. There's no doubting his talent. The big issue with making a move for him is we would have to be confident that he would sign a new contract when he can opt out two years from now - at that point he'd be 27 years old - and that could result in us trading for a guy that doesn't stay and leaves us back at square one.
So once again we would be in that Cousins like situation. If we don't show enough progress and start to show we can be least a play off team heading towards a higher seed, then there is a good chance a player like Irving could leave for a better situation - and at 27 years old he'll have no shortage of suitors. However, if we show enough progress, make the play offs, and show we could be a higher seed, then there's a chance he could re-sign with us - but even in his situation he could get his head turned.
I'll be honest, I'd love to see him join us but it's risky. We aren't in OKC's position where they are going all in on trying to win a championship with Westbrook. I could understand taking the risk if we still had Cousins and wanted to pair another all star with him, but we don't have him anymore. We have mostly young talent with some veterans. At best I could see us being an outside play off contender this season, and without any further moves or breakouts that is probably our ceiling.
I suppose to some a return to the play offs would be good news, but unless he signs a long term deal when he can opt out or before that year comes, we could end up sacrificing young talent for a player that leaves at the first opportunity to do so. Now if Fox's ceiling is Elfrid Payton, and WCS becomes nothing more than an average center, then I suppose sacrificing them for a proven all star and betting on him re-signing and making us better might be worth it. However, if Fox does have star potential and achieves it, and WCS can be more than an average center, then we might kick ourselves for doing a deal (especially if Irving leaves).
For me, I'd stay the course and bet on our young talent developing into stars. Though I wouldn't complain if we did trade for Irving just as long as we don't give up too much.