http://www.sacbee.com/100/story/29018.html
Ailene Voisin: Nolan chooses the safe approach
He gives up the ball, and some swagger, with a punt.
By Ailene Voisin - Bee Sports Columnist
Last Updated 12:12 am PDT Monday, September 25, 2006
All those heady comments about nearing NFL puberty, about avoiding a replay from a season ago, and this is all Mike Nolan has to say for himself?
So what does this say to his team?
When under duress, punt? Retreat?
Whatever happened to the man's strut?
When pressed afterward about his case of the yips -- about choosing to go meekly into the locker room at halftime of Sunday's loss to the visiting Philadelphia Eagles, eschewing a closing opportunity on fourth and one from the opponent's 40-yard line -- Nolan explained he played it safe. And, probably, he played it smart. He opted for truth over dare, in essence, acknowledged what became increasingly obvious throughout the afternoon -- namely, that these 49ers just aren't quite ready to take the big risk. The next step, perhaps, but not the big risk.
"They (Eagles) had 338 yards at that point," the 49ers' second-year coach said after his club's 38-24 defeat at Monster Park. "They were about two first downs max from three more points. As bad as 24-3 is, it sure beats 27-3 or 31-3. Three touchdowns in the second half ... I didn't think we were that far from getting that. I think we could have done that."
Retreat, then regroup. That seemed to be the message. No more time for fumbles. No more missed assignments. No more failures in the red zone, and certainly, no more of those signature sequences, the one in which 6-foot, 292-pound defensive tackle Mike Patterson lumbers 98 yards on a fumble recovery, dragging poor Alex Smith along for the latter part of the journey.
Maybe Nolan was right. Maybe when all those developments occur, it's wise to accept defeat and move on to the second half.
But, geez, couldn't he have faked it a little bit? Maybe faked the punt and provided the announced 68,166 spectators -- and his players -- a modicum of drama? Before Sunday's struggles, the 49ers were the young and the restless. Against the Eagles, they were young and resilient. Mostly, though, they were just young.
"I said at the beginning of the week that I thought this game had the possibility of being a statement game," Nolan said. "What I meant by that is ... I thought with a victory today, we could become a team with an expectation to win as opposed to a hope to win. Certainly today we didn't play well enough to win the game."
Beginning with the first play, a flea flicker that resulted in a 50-yard gain and led to the first of Brian Westbrook's three touchdowns, the 49ers -- like their coach afterward -- went on the defensive. Donovan McNabb repeatedly located open receivers for large gains. Westbrook burst up the middle as if all of the 49ers' linemen suddenly had become binge dieters, once sprinting for 71 yards (the longest Eagles run in six years) and one impressive stiff arm of free safety Mike Adams. The Eagles' faster, stronger defensive linemen harassed Smith throughout the afternoon, and when they caught up with him, took turns slamming him to the turf.
Nonetheless, Smith continues to show promise, and progress. The second-year starter completed 27 of his 46 passes for 293 yards and a touchdown, and at times stubbornly stayed in the pocket, other times scampered for first downs. And if he became demoralized by the large early deficit, it never was apparent; he played with poise, and equally important, played with an attitude. Needless to say, he wasn't thrilled with Nolan's decision to punt rather than, say, pass, either.
"I always like to go for it," said Smith, grinning, "but I'm not the head coach."
What had to hurt worse than any bruises was the fact that, on that final drive of the half, the 49ers finally gained an offensive rhythm. There was Smith, finding Frank Gore and Maurice Hicks over the middle, connecting with tight end Eric Johnson for 14 yards, Gore scooting for another couple of decent gains, the 49ers moving to the Eagles' 40 in the waning seconds of the opening half. Then on third and one, Gore was stopped for no gain, setting up the much-debated situation, the one with Nolan directing the 49ers to punt rather than strive for the big play.
Asked if he was concerned his decision might be interpreted as a lack of confidence in (and by) his players, or whether he worried about a repeat of 2005, when a loss to these same Eagles triggered a landslide of losses, the coach demurred.
"Different team, different year," he insisted forcefully. "Last year they just flat kicked our butt. This year, we did a good job kicking our own butt."
The hope is that, next time, the 49ers do the kicking.
Or better yet, don't do the kicking.
About the writer: Reach Ailene Voisin at (916) 321-1208 or avoisin@ sacbee.com