Vince Young to the Raiders?

#1
A very intriguing prospect brought up in SI's most recent mock draft with the recent developments @ quarterback around the league.

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2006/writers/don_banks/03/14/mock.draft3.part1/index.html

1 Texans - RB Reggie Bush USC Jr. 6-0 200 The bottom 31 slots in this first round might wind up looking vastly different between now and the April 29 draft, but I'm convinced Bush and the Texans are a marriage that's going to last. At least until I start hearing that Houston is seriously entertaining offers to trade down.

2 Jets (trade) - QB Matt Leinart USC Sr. 6-5 225 Now that the Saints have signed Drew Brees and don't need the best quarterback available at this spot, look for the Jets to move up and get the former Heisman Trophy winner. Although they did work out a deal with Chad Pennington, this is too good an opportunity to turn down.

3 Titans - QB Jay Cutler Vanderbilt Sr. 6-4 228 Nobody had more buzz coming out of Indy than Cutler, and I'm sticking with the idea that the hometown Titans are intrigued with keeping the Vandy star in Nashville. But having Mario Williams sitting there for the taking is going to really test Tennessee's belief in Cutler.

4 Saints (trade) - DE Mario Williams N.C. State Jr. 6-7 285 Since the quarterback spot seems to be settled, the Saints need to replace free-agent defensive end Darren Howard, who signed a big deal with the Eagles. Williams is a rare physical specimen who could be a matchup problem for opposing defenses.

5 Packers - DT Haloti Ngata Oregon Jr. 6-5 345 With the Packers re-signing defensive end Aaron Kampman, they now turn their attention to the defensive interior, where the run-stuffing Ngata is the best the draft has to offer. Taking the draft's blue-chip offensive tackle, Virginia's D'Brickashaw Ferguson, would also be a sound top-five strategy.

6 Niners - OT D'Brickashaw Ferguson Virginia Sr. 6-5 295 We can't think of a better way to aid in the development of second-year franchise quarterback Alex Smith than a cornerstone left tackle to protect his backside for the foreseeable future.

7 Raiders - QB Vince Young Texas Jr. 6-5 235 Given that the Raiders have failed at landing Daunte Culpepper, this move makes too much sense. As crazy as it would have sounded on the morning of Jan. 5 after his Rose Bowl showing, if Young slips past the Raiders, it's possible he could fall entirely out of the top 10.
 
Last edited:
#2
I wouldn't touch him in the Top 10. There are 10 guys in this draft who will be elite at their position, and Young is not one of them. They should jump on Hawk or Davis if the draft unfolded as above. With that recieving corp all they need is a guy who can stand in the pocket and sling it, which they already have in Walter. Young would be a mistake.

Those elite are:

RB-Bush
QB-Leinart
Cutler (debatable)
DE-Williams
DT-Ngata
OT-Ferguson
LB-Hawk
TE-Davis
S-Huff
Williams
 
#3
Venom said:
I wouldn't touch him in the Top 10. There are 10 guys in this draft who will be elite at their position, and Young is not one of them. They should jump on Hawk or Davis if the draft unfolded as above. With that recieving corp all they need is a guy who can stand in the pocket and sling it, which they already have in Walter. Young would be a mistake.

Those elite are:

RB-Bush
QB-Leinart
Cutler (debatable)
DE-Williams
DT-Ngata
OT-Ferguson
LB-Hawk
TE-Davis
S-Huff
Williams
that is just your personal opinion. unfortunately none of those guys are the reigning rose bowl mvps and certainly have not dominated such a huge game like Vince did. I think NFL execs may see things differently than you. he deserves 3rd pick at worst.
 
#4
atxrocker said:
that is just your personal opinion. unfortunately none of those guys are the reigning rose bowl mvps and certainly have not dominated such a huge game like Vince did. I think NFL execs may see things differently than you. he deserves 3rd pick at worst.

He will definitely not go top 3 unless there are at least two trades. Neither the Texans nor the Saints need a QB. Vince Young's stock has steadily declined since the Rose Bowl. He played in a one-read shotgun offense, has poor mechanics, questionable arm strength, and either terrible or very average intelligence depending on which Wonderlic story you believe. His representation throughout this process has been abysmal. Moreover, Texas stars in general, and Mack Brown players in particular, have been first round busts. Brown does not prepare his stars well for the next level.

All of the above means that the buyer had better beware, and in a draft loaded w/ players who grade out as elite, Vince Young will slide.
 
#6
atxrocker said:
looks like Tennessee disagreed and took him at 3, where i figured he would go. good for him, good for the nfl!
Time will tell. The owner overruled the coaching staff in making the selection, with the apparent backing of the GM. Of course, Fisher did not want McNair either. It will be interesting to watch his progression. The pressure may mount to play him early, as I think both Leinart and Cutler are going to have at least moderate success within 2 years.