LaTroy Hawkins traded to Giants...

SLAB

Hall of Famer
#1
Giants acquire setup man Hawkins
Williams, Aardsma sent to Chicago for reliever
05/28/2005 1:37 PM ET

SAN FRANCISCO -- In a move that adds a premier set-up man to their bullpen, the San Francisco Giants have acquired right-handed pitcher LaTroy Hawkins and cash from the Chicago Cubs in exchange for right-handers Jerome Williams and David Aardsma, club Senior Vice President and General Manager Brian Sabean announced today.

Hawkins, who fashioned a 15-3 record with 41 holds and a 2.00 ERA (35er, 157.2ip) as the primary set-up man on Minnesota's 2002 and 2003 AL Central champions, will serve as the seventh and eighth-inning bridge to Giants closer Tyler Walker, who is tied for the National League lead with six saves since May 12.

"LaTroy's acquisition certainly strengthens and deepens our bullpen, which obviously needs bolstering," said Sabean.

During Hawkins' two-year stint as the Twins' eighth-inning man, his 2.00 ERA was the third-lowest among all American League relievers, while Minnesota closer Eddie Guardado led the junior circuit with a combined 86 saves. In addition, Hawkins' 138 strikeouts were the fourth-most by an American League relief hurler from 2002-03.

A veteran of parts of 11 big league seasons, the 6-5, 215-pound hurler posted 25 saves with a 2.63 ERA (24er, 82.0ip) for the Chicago Cubs in 2004, and had logged a 3.32 mark (7er, 19.0ip) in 21 relief outings this year for the South Siders. Originally a starter at the Major League level, the 31-year-old was converted to a reliever in 2000 and has forged a 24-21 ledger with 73 saves and a 3.10 ERA (138er, 400.2ip) in 366 relief outings. In fact, he's limited opponents to a .246 lifetime batting average (371-for-1,509) as a reliever and has not allowed more hits than innings pitched in each of last four seasons.

Williams, who in 2004 became San Francisco's youngest 10-game winner since 1975, was 0-2 with a 6.48 ERA (12er, 16.2ip) over four games (three starts) before being optioned to triple-A Fresno on April 25. The 23-year-old has since struggled in the Pacific Coast League, going 1-4 with a 9.36 ERA (32er, 30.2ip) in six starts for the Grizzlies. Originally the Giants' sandwich selection (39th pick overall) in the 1999 First-Year Player Draft, Williams owns a 17-14 career record with a 3.93 ERA (121er, 277.0ip) in 47 big league games (46 starts).

Aardsma, San Francisco's top selection (23rd player chosen overall) in the 2003 First-Year Player Draft, had made a successful conversion to a starting pitcher this year at double-A Norwich. The all-time saves leader at Rice University was 6-2 with a 2.93 ERA (15er, 46.0ip) in nine games (eight starts) for the Navigators. In 11 games with the Giants in 2004, the 23-year-old went 1-0 with a 6.75 ERA (8er, 10.2ip).

http://sanfrancisco.giants.mlb.com/...ent_id=1065885&vkey=news_sf&fext=.jsp&c_id=sf
 
Last edited:

SLAB

Hall of Famer
#2
I was quite honestly shocked when I first read this, but since I have cooled off just a bit.

Williams has been struggling MIGHTILY, 1 and 4 with a 9.30 ERA in AAA. There may be something wrong with him? Who knows. But on the flip side he is only 23!

The Giants DO have a lot of young starters in their system, though. Matt Cain, Jesse Foppert, Alfredo Simon...You can only start so many people on a MLB team, so dealing a starter won't necessarily hurt to bad in the long run.

David Aardsma is what got me. Supposedly "everyone was calling" about the Giants young pitching prospects last year. Thats great, so you turn two of our good young prospects into LaTroy Hawkins?! Aardsma was widley regarded as the Giants closer of the future. He throws upper ninteys, and can pitch. I guess the Giants are putting hope in the rest of their youngins...Valdez, Correia, Accardo, Munter.

What I see the deal as...Two 23 year olds with loads of potential for a set-up man that is what he is.

Bad deal.
 
#3
I was pretty shocked too. I guess Sabean still believes that the Giants can win big this year- and I can't say that I totally disagree, assuming that Bonds is back at the break at anything even close to full strength. Tyler Walker has been holding the fort excellently in place of Benitez, so maybe the thinking is that Aardsma won't be needed as a closer with Walker, Hawkins and Benitez all potential closers for the next 3 years. When Benitez comes back our bullpen will be deeper than it has been in a long time. Trading Williams definitely seems odd to me...he was amazing back in '03, but he has been slowing down. I guess the assumption is that Foppert, Cain and Lowry are the best young pitchers and that Williams was more of a flash in the pan.

IF Bonds comes back, IF Benitez comes back, and IF this team can make the playoffs, this will be a great deal, giving us a sturdy bullpen to complement some decent, potentially good starting pitching and a potent offense.

On the other hand, I can't help but think about the Ledee-for-Rodriguez deal, which I still can't get my head around that could easily have cost us the '04 season because our bullpen could have held a lead in one more game down the stretch.
 

6th

Homer Fan Since 1985
#4
I have been a SF Giants fan for about 25 years. I have been a Chicago Cubs fan for about 40 years (#2 only to the Giants for the past 25 years). I do not like this trade at all. Why? Because Hawkins is a crappy pitcher. 50% as a closer really sucks. All my family who are Cubs fans dislike Hawkins as well.

So now, my Cubs get rid of Hawkins, but he goes to the only team that is ranked higher with me than the Cubs. **sigh**
 

SLAB

Hall of Famer
#5
Well, he'll at least be a set-up man in San Fran, and hopefully, Alou will have enough brainpower to know that he isn't a closer.
 

6th

Homer Fan Since 1985
#6
SLAB said:
Well, he'll at least be a set-up man in San Fran, and hopefully, Alou will have enough brainpower to know that he isn't a closer.
Hopefully that will help, SLAB. He was pretty decent as a set up man, but he has sure given up a lot of runs as a closer. Hopefully, the change in mind set will be all he'll need to get it back together. I really really hope so. **sigh**
 

SLAB

Hall of Famer
#7
He was pretty decent as a set up man
He was actually lights out as a set-up man in Minnesota, so hopefully he'll have a clean slate, and return to his super set-up form as a Giant...I hope...
 
#8
hawkins is a great setup man. anybody who can use him in the 7th and 8th innings is set. but the man simply crumbles under pressure. he was one of the main reasons the cubs didn't make it into the playoffs last year. he blew 4 crucial saves in the last week or so. i'm glad he's gone. cubs aint goin anywhere anyway, he can go blow saves for other teams as far as i'm concerned. i guess dusty baker figures he's not going to use him as middle relief so he might as well get rid of him.