There's a big difference in Haliburton for Simmons and Haliburton + multiple first round picks for Simmons.
Simmons is superior but he's not worth losing Haliburton's contributions plus a few first round picks for. You aren't just trading for 15, 7 and 7 with elite defense Simmons. You're trading for all the baggage that comes along with that and that has a cost to it. You let the Sixers off the hook if the latter is disregarded. Hali for Simmons? Ok, but you need to have Fox lined up to be traded in another deal. Hali for Simmons + a FRP? We're talking. Anything more than that? Kick rocks. It's not like our FRPs are in the 20s. They have a lot of value to them.
This franchise only has a few avenues to acquire talent. Simmons isn't Embiid and can't carry a team on his own. You don't just hand the keys over to him with low level role players and perennial losing players and make a run at it without the ability to draft any talent for the next few years.
Simmons is superior but he's not worth losing Haliburton's contributions plus a few first round picks for. You aren't just trading for 15, 7 and 7 with elite defense Simmons. You're trading for all the baggage that comes along with that and that has a cost to it. You let the Sixers off the hook if the latter is disregarded. Hali for Simmons? Ok, but you need to have Fox lined up to be traded in another deal. Hali for Simmons + a FRP? We're talking. Anything more than that? Kick rocks. It's not like our FRPs are in the 20s. They have a lot of value to them.
This franchise only has a few avenues to acquire talent. Simmons isn't Embiid and can't carry a team on his own. You don't just hand the keys over to him with low level role players and perennial losing players and make a run at it without the ability to draft any talent for the next few years.
Marvin Bagley
De’Aaron Fox
Justin Jackson
Harry Giles
Georgios Papagiannis
Malachi Richardson
Skal Labissiere
Willie Cauley-Stein
Nik Stauskas
Ben McLemore
Thomas Robinson
Jimmer Fredette
DeMarcus Cousins
Tyreke Evans
Jason Thompson
Spencer Hawes
Quincy Douby
Francisco Garcia
Kevin Martin
Because that's what we're actually talking about here. It's nice to think we're going to pick a great player every year in the first round but we won't. At least 50% of our future picks are going to amount to nothing and if past history is any indication the rest are probably going to keep us in 35 win purgatory forever.
I think fate handed us a gift in the form of an MVP level player with the second pick of the 2018 draft and we said "no thanks". Now fate is handing us a gift again in the form of a 25 year old budding superstar who is a perfect fit for a team that can't stop anyone from scoring for more than 5 minutes a game and we're ready to make the same mistake again. For what? The vague hope that doing the same thing over and over again will somehow yield different results?
Tyrese Haliburton is a great young player. Nobody needs to feel sorry for him being traded to Philadelphia to play in front of sell out crowds and compete for a championship every year alongside the best big man of this generation. And nobody is going to give away one of their best players without getting something of value in return. I don't think we're in any position to be dictating the terms here. We have one asset Philadelphia wants and we just have to wrap him in some monopoly money to help Daryl Morey save face. It's easy to sit over here and lob stones because of a situation we know very little about but Ben Simmons actually makes us relevant in the NBA conversation again.